Everyone on this board should TRULY adhear and pay very close attention to what you have said...I couldn't have put it better myself. It's not about debating...it's about sharing personal experience in the hopes that it will keep you motivated and encourage others.
Unfortunately, what I am seeing from some members (especially the "long timers") is their passion for what they have done (to various degrees of success), eliminates their ability to see that the "one size fits all" approach is simply not true. Their passion doesn't seem to allow them to accept another point of view and it is taken as a "debate" instead of a discussion.
I think that instead of simply listening and "running away" from a conversation, it would be more helpful if people just simply posted what they felt and gave people who have has success otherwise the respect by agreeing to disagree.
In the end, you will find that there are "shiploads" of people who have experienced success on various modifications of Atkins/Southbeach, etc., etc. Here's to everyone's health and success...I wish everyone on this post the very best. Let's stay positive and proactive...not reactive!
Quote:
Originally Posted by mandalinn82
Well, I don't follow a low carb plan, but my response to people who think there is only ONE way to lose weight, with no regard to individual body composition, metabolic differences, and just plain food preferences, has always been "Different things work for different people, since our bodies vary so much. I'm really happy to have found something that works for me".
To her, Atkins might never work (she might not be able to give up those morning carbs, who knows? I tried a low carb approach and it never worked for me, even when following Dr. A's book to the T...I barely dropped any weight and it was impossible for me to stick to. Just wasn't right for my body chemistry). For you, it works, and that is all that matters. Getting into throwing studies at eachother, or citing research, won't get you anywhere in my experience - you'll just go back and forth because there have been studies going either way.
My personal belief is that these sort of arguments arise when people want to throw a one-size-fits-all approach onto weight loss. Different things work for different people, and acknowledging that will, again in my experience, make her less likely to debate you.