3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community

3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/)
-   Calorie Counters (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/calorie-counters-172/)
-   -   Big Cookie Temptation (https://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/calorie-counters/135525-big-cookie-temptation.html)

jellydisney 02-27-2008 07:07 AM

Big Cookie Temptation
 
Everyday in my cafeteria they have these enormous (4 1/2 inch) sugar cookies and chocolate chip cookies with frosting. They are so tempting, and every single day I have to look at them and try to resist. They don't list the calories though... how many calories do you think would be in a 4.5 inch sugar cookie with chocolate frosting? Fitday is no help lol... :devil:

Spiritmagejkt 02-27-2008 07:11 AM

probably more than you want to eat. You can sorta guess from fitday with similar foods. It depends if the frosting is made with lard. If its not refrigerated it probably is. Your looking at 400 calories probably

Meg 02-27-2008 07:13 AM

Ack! My downfall too. I can't let myself have the first bite, else I'd never stop. :devil:

I'm always tempted by the ones at Starbucks, which sound like they're about the same size but without icing. Starbucks nutritional info has them at 370 - 500 calories, depending on the variety, so maybe that's a ballpark guess?

brookelizabeth 02-27-2008 08:01 AM

Same thing at my work but they alternate the goodies. I told the ladies who work at our lunch counter that I am not to order any of it and they help me. There are times when I wish I hadn't done that but it does help! Frosting is my number one thing. I had a dream about a cupcake the other night...
:mouse:

rockinrobin 02-27-2008 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jellydisney (Post 2074540)
Everyday in my cafeteria they have these enormous (4 1/2 inch) sugar cookies and chocolate chip cookies with frosting. They are so tempting, and every single day I have to look at them and try to resist. They don't list the calories though... how many calories do you think would be in a 4.5 inch sugar cookie with chocolate frosting? Fitday is no help lol... :devil:

WAAAAAY TOOO MANY!!!! And SOOO not worth it. Good for you for resisting. It IS hard isn't it?

Keep this is mind, it just may make resisting some what easier - somebody told me last week that they read an article titled, "If Sugar Were Discovered Today, It Would Be Classified as a DRUG." A drug? Can you believe it? :yes:

And check out this article from TIME:

http://www.time.com/time/health/arti...703644,00.html

vealcalf2000 02-27-2008 08:18 AM

I can believe it about Sugar being classified as a drug if it were found today! Goodness with diabetes on the rise and you know it's all from sugars and carbs that turn into sugar! I try to stay clear but like any "drug" you crave it!

Azure 02-27-2008 08:20 AM

I've learned, through many-a trial and error that I just need to stay away from sugar--for me, that means straight up sugar and refined carbohydrates. I love sugar cookies as much as the next person, and buttercream frosting... Well, I could eat half a jar of it in a sitting. I have eaten 3/4 of a bag of mint oreo cookies in a sitting, too. I just can't stop myself when I have sugar ;) I'd say an extra 300-500 calories at lunch definitely isn't worth it--and it especially isn't worth it if it might trigger you to eat more sugar. :) That's just my .02 worth.

2beautiful2Bfat 02-27-2008 08:26 AM

could you buy a cookie on mondays as a trreat and cut it into 4 pieces and then baggie it an eat one piece a day. That woudl only be a 100 calories.

Azure 02-27-2008 08:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2beautiful2Bfat (Post 2074645)
could you buy a cookie on mondays as a trreat and cut it into 4 pieces and then baggie it an eat one piece a day. That woudl only be a 100 calories.

People who can do things like that amaze me. :)

rockinrobin 02-27-2008 08:39 AM

Or how about finding 3 or 4 other people to SHARE it with, on the spot?
No bagging it up or thinking about it laying around.

nelie 02-27-2008 09:03 AM

I saw some big cookies at Whole Foods and was curious how many calories they had in them. 500. Way too much.

azmom 02-27-2008 02:28 PM

I'm with Azure!
Sugar takes over my soul after just a little nibble! I am better completely staying away from it. I lose my cravings after a while anyways!
I am trying to only put food in my body that has mega nutritional content!!
Cookies are from the devil!!

2beautiful2Bfat 02-27-2008 02:40 PM

I guess I have gotten good at this will power thing. Dh bought me a box of truffles for v-day and I promised myself I would eat one every day and I have done exactly that except some days I don't have any. He bought me 10 and I have 1 left for later today.

Anyways I had another idea. What about baking your own healthy cookies that taste good and aren't loaded in calories and bringing those to work once in awhile.

rockinrobin 02-27-2008 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2beautiful2Bfat (Post 2075303)
What about baking your own healthy cookies that taste good and aren't loaded in calories and bringing those to work once in awhile.

Okay, I NEED a recipe for these babies. Healthy? Tastes good? AND aren't loaded with calories? Do tell. Do tell.

nelie 02-27-2008 02:55 PM

Not cookies, but I've been using vitamuffin mixes. They are awesome :)

I eat chocolate almost every day. A little piece of it. Recently, I did buy myself some really good truffles and I didn't want to dig into them one after another which was amazing. I do plan to have 1 every day though until they are gone. And I can't buy them again until the end of summer (they only ship out in the cooler months)

midwife 02-27-2008 03:06 PM

If you eat a 500 calorie cookie every day,
that is 3500 calories week,
and that is 52 pounds of stored fat in a year.

Be strong. The temptation will pass and you will celebrate your willpower!

souvenirdarling 02-27-2008 04:16 PM

I live off of 80 cal pudding cups and 60 cal caramel mousse cups and lots of yogurt. Fits into my plan and keeps my sweet tooth sated :)

coldbrightday 02-27-2008 04:20 PM

I make these tasty bars with almond meal, flax meal, egg, coconut oil, vanilla extract, and a leeetle bit of honey or agave. They're quite dense -- definitely not low calorie, but they're very low sugar and no refined carbs at all, which for me at least, means I can have one little square and satisfy my craving for baked goods without hopping on the carbo train to bingeville.

Sorry I don't have a recipe on hand, I just experimented with ratios until I got a texture I liked.

jellydisney 02-27-2008 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockinrobin (Post 2074608)

And check out this article from TIME:

http://www.time.com/time/health/arti...703644,00.html

Wow, I can feel my arteries clogging just looking at that picture of fried chicken and biscuits!

Literally, yesterday, I had the cookie in my hand (it has a plastic wrapping) and I put it back down. The struggle for willpower was insane. I think I need to just not even go near that corner of the cafeteria, as a rule.

jellydisney 02-27-2008 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by souvenirdarling (Post 2075455)
I live off of 80 cal pudding cups and 60 cal caramel mousse cups and lots of yogurt. Fits into my plan and keeps my sweet tooth sated :)

Ooh, where can I get 60 calorie caramel mousse cups?? Do tell!

jellydisney 02-27-2008 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by midwife (Post 2075337)
If you eat a 500 calorie cookie every day,
that is 3500 calories week,
and that is 52 pounds of stored fat in a year.

Be strong. The temptation will pass and you will celebrate your willpower!

Thank you for that. That definitely helps. Even just one cookie a week is 26,000 calories a year, which is 7.5 lbs a year. Not worth it!!

You know what I think the biggest problem is? I'm quite hungry by lunchtime (even though I have a planned snack at 10 am), and EVERYTHING looks good. I have my healthy chicken breast with veggies and I see the cookies, and the hunger gets the best of me. It's like going grocery shopping while you're hungry. A recipe for disaster!

dgramie 02-27-2008 07:50 PM

If you are craving chocolate what about a mini candy bar. Hersey bar mini are really good for satifying a craving and only has 40 calories. I keep them on hand for a real emergency. LIke when TOM is here. I ony eat a half of one or a whole one.Its alot better than eating a reg size candy bar.

souvenirdarling 02-27-2008 08:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jellydisney (Post 2075695)
Ooh, where can I get 60 calorie caramel mousse cups?? Do tell!

The brand is "kooll desserts" and they make little yogurt cup sized desserts.
The mousse ones are called "Mooss". I got them at my grocery store *shrug*. They have really annoying commercials :)

zenor77 02-27-2008 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockinrobin (Post 2075311)
Okay, I NEED a recipe for these babies. Healthy? Tastes good? AND aren't loaded with calories? Do tell. Do tell.

I make cookies quite frequently. Whole wheat pastry flour gets substituted for the all purpose and sugar can be cut down by at least 1/3 in most recipes with no difference in texture of the product. I like to find recipes that use oil versus shortening, but I will occasionally use palm shortening or butter.

The main calorie cutting that I do is to use a 1T cookie scoop. They are small, but if you look at older recipes this is the real size cookies are supposed to be. I always get the amount that the recipe says it makes when I use the scoop.

Most of the cookies I make end up somewhere in the 50-80 calorie per cookie range. I usually eat only two cookies at one time.

Of course if sugar gives you cravings then these tips won't help.

brookelizabeth 02-27-2008 10:38 PM

The people who sit around me are gaining weight because I feed them what I want but shouldn't have lol I do tend to share a lot. :D

rockinrobin 02-28-2008 06:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zenor77 (Post 2075970)
I make cookies quite frequently. Whole wheat pastry flour gets substituted for the all purpose and sugar can be cut down by at least 1/3 in most recipes with no difference in texture of the product. I like to find recipes that use oil versus shortening, but I will occasionally use palm shortening or butter.

The main calorie cutting that I do is to use a 1T cookie scoop. They are small, but if you look at older recipes this is the real size cookies are supposed to be. I always get the amount that the recipe says it makes when I use the scoop.

Most of the cookies I make end up somewhere in the 50-80 calorie per cookie range. I usually eat only two cookies at one time.

Of course if sugar gives you cravings then these tips won't help.

Thanks for the ideas Zenor. But truth be told, me and home baked goods do NOT get along. I have no control with them and therefore are better off doing without them completely. And cookies in general. Our dear Meg passed on a quote the other week and it kind of sums me up to a T -

"One cookie is too many and a dozen are not enough."

So yeah, until a 5 calorie cookie is invented, I'm gonna have to take a pass. ;)


Jellydisney, you are amazing. You actually had the cookie in your hand and put it back? Well good for you!!!! You should be very proud of yourself. You came away from the situation unscathed :carrot:.

If you're starving by lunchtime, maybe you need to have a larger, more satisfying snack at 10:00. But for sure, STAY AWAY FROM THE COOKIE SECTION. The BIG cookie section. :hug:

JayEll 02-28-2008 08:33 AM

:drill: Step away from the cookie! :drill:

:coach: What part about "weight loss" don't you understand?

:lol:

They are always going to look good to you. It's unlikely that you'll ever get to a point where they don't. However, as long as you don't give in to your desire, it will get easier and easier to pass them up. So, hang in there! You are making good choices! Don't let a cookie tell you what to do! ;)

Jay


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:40 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.