I prefer my digital scale! I think it's easier to see your progress... because even if you only lose, like, .2 pounds, that's still a loss and It's easier to see on a digital scale.
I have both...but I like the digital the best...because it does half pounds too...and sometimes when it's early in the morning, I can read the digital better than having to squint to read the other scale
I love my digital one. First I can see it without my glasses (which I don't wear as they could make me a tiny bit heavier!!), and second it does the .2 increments. I keep the regular one around though, just in case the digital gives me a weight I don't believe.