I lost more on P1, but I had alot more to lose, too. For me, SBD is about so much more than weight loss. I am 52, and have been following SBD for just over a year now. When I follow this WOE as a catylist for super postitive health benefits, I am always happy and take the WL as an added benefit.
I believe you will lose weight, but it will come off at it's own pace while you are getting healthier daily. It sounds like you are already practicing other healthy habits such as exercising and drinking water...you just need to add healthy food habits. The chicks who didn't have so much to lose will chime in, too. I didn't take my measurements when I started SBD, but I know I lose inches many times when I'm not losing pounds. Feel free to post a typical day's menu, too, and we can see if there's anything we could suggest that might help.