Quote:
Originally Posted by ange82much
I completely agree with you all that food reduction is 90% of the job, however AnnRue's proposed scope is do-able I think, and would definitely improve health, wellbeing, etc etc as well as the calorie deficit - so I say YES in this case - do the extra moving for 400cal per day and get your weight-loss and all the other benefits thrown in! Most people are too lazy/busy to churn out another 400 cals per day on exercise but if you're motivated I think it's a great way to go. The only problem then would be keeping it up long-term because it would be easy to not do this for a day every now and then, and be unwilling to cut 400cals from the diet which would throw out your weekly averages quite a lot - so would you therefore aim for 500 per day and therefore build in a 'day off' every week as a contingency? But then that's a LOT of exercise....
Bless you for a reasoned response to my post. It is quite impossible for me to burn off 400 calories a day via exercise. I work a long job and would not have the time OR the energy to do so. I also don't think it is sustainable for a long time period. We all have those times where we just can't do it.
So the 500 deficit from TDEE has to be made up of.
- a small decrease in calories (150 per day under the BMR)
- weight lifting to increase metabolism. 4% or so (extra 85 calories burned on BMR)
- a daily exercise you do anyway -- walking around work for 10 hours. (300 calories)
- a small 20 or 30 minute extra exercise period per day. (100 calories - walking or something at lunch)
An interesting thing that happened to me. I have been on a diet at least every year since 2006. Likely all too little food. My vitals came down significantly. So much so that my doctor always is stumped as to why I am fat but still have low BP and low heart rate (or normal). Well since I have made an active attempt to eat more food and rev the metabolism... my blood pressure has gone up 20 pts ( but this is good because it is now normal) and my BP has gone from 60 and lower at night to 75. I feel so much better and have more energy with a normal BP and heart rate. And frankly some information suggests that heart rate is directly related to metabolism.
Have I lost weight? No. But it is hard to tell. I have seen that when you start a weight training program you can gain from 3 to 8 lbs of muscle/ water. So my scale hasn't really moved in over a month. So seems to me that I am not going to see a reduction in my scale until I have lost 8 or more lbs of fat... (approximately 8 months or more in). Have I lost inches... well it is hard to say but definitely last week I put something on that was too tight for me and thought... this seems loose. If after 8 months I have lost zero on the scale, I will drop my calories by 100 and start using fasting to make sure I am burning fat over glycogen.