Quote:
Originally Posted by Stars
Yep! But I read that starvation mode was a myth entirely. Either way, I agree with your entire post!
It's entirely a myth that metabolism stops dead in it's tracks (preventing starvation and weight loss entirely) but it's entirely true that metabolism can (not necessarily will, but can) slow down significantly.
Many of the studies that found no evidence of metabolic slowing whatsoever used young, healthy, and average weight subjects and/or used subjects who had little or no dieting experience.
Personally, from my experience (42 years of dieting) I suspect that for many of us, metabolic slowing or "conservation mode" (a better description I think) is a very gradual process that takes years of chronic dieting to become noticeable. Rather than our metabolism stopping dead, or rapidly declining, it instead chips away very slowly over time, like a mountain being eroded by wind.
I know for myself, when I was young metabolism calculators (the ones that estimate calorie needs) were accurate or even underestimated my calorie needs. I lost as much or more than what they predicted I would. Then in my early 20's I would guess, they gradually became less and less helpful in predicting my calorie needs and weight loss, and I'd lose more slowly than the calculator predicted. Over time, the discrepancy became larger and larger as I lost more and more slowly.
That leaves essentially indicates one of two possibilities - conservation mode eroding my metabolism over time due to yoyo dieting or unknown factors causing my metabolism to slow faster than average (as the calculations are based on average populations) for unknown reasons.
In my youth, I actually found that I had an above average metabolism. Even though I was only moderately active, I often lost significantly faster than the calculators predicted. Metabolism wasn't my problem then, uncontrollable, constant hunger was.
Ironically, by the time I learned how to control hunger, my metabolism had slowed considerably.
At any rate, starvation mode, as most people think of it, is a complete myth, but there are elements of truth that contributed to the creation of the myth (like most myths, a small truth is bent and twisted into a big lie).