Amy, have you tried the chocolate lite shake with the water and also a serving of low fat yogurt. Of course, it makes it thicker and more like a real chocolate malt kind of shake. Also, it is a good way to combine foods and use up a dairy. I also like the vanilla with fruit. My fav being with strawberries.
Merem - I have tried the hot cocoa mix, the mixed berry and also the strawberry kiwi. I like them, but my favorites are still the lite shakes.
Thinner is better...........