Pears from Harry & David.
A hand-made mug or two, tea-ball and small amount of loose tea and/or fun selection of tea-bags.
1 lb of excellent coffee from a local coffee shop.
A small, hand-made lovely wooden cutting board.
However, wine is the perfect gift and giving wine at Thanksgiving is really easy. Beaujolais Nouveau always hits the stores JUST in time for Thanksgiving. It's a very young wine, intended for immediate drinking, perfectly affordable and absolutely in keeping with the season - it is a wine of the year, a harvest celebration, just like Thanksgiving.
Regardless of their tastes, it is a perfect wine to give at Thanksgiving. Wine Enthusiast has a great
run down of this year's crop of beaujolais nouveau.
And if they don't want to drink it, they can always
bathe in it.