When I was first diagnosed with diabetes I tried a bunch of different sugar free syrups and I found three that my whole family likes.
1. Cary's Sugar Free syrup (30 calories per 1/4 cup) It is the least expensive and is in my cubbard right now, so I could check the calorie count. Rate: 8
2. Mrs.Butterworth's- usually more expensive than Cary's, so I only buy it when on sale or I have a coupon. Rate: 8
3. Cracker Barrel Sugar Free Syrup- The nearest Cracker Barrel is about 20 miles away, so I only get this one when I am doing other shopping in that area. Rate: 10
I tried other brands and find them either to thin, or just not maple syrupy (is that a word?) enough.