Weight and Resistance Training - What Happens When We Stop Working Out?




Meg
02-23-2006, 08:40 PM
Have you ever wondered what would happen if you stopped working out? I’ve had the opportunity to find out over the last seven weeks and it ain’t pretty, let me tell you. :p But it’s been a fascinating object lesson in why we lift weights (and will never ever quit!) so I want to share it with all of you.

Here’s what’s been going on …

Right Side: I had surgery seven weeks ago on my right shoulder and wasn’t allowed to do anything to fire the muscles on the right side for six weeks. My arm was completely immobilized 24/7 in a sling (except for passive stretching in physical therapy three times a week) (ow). I’ve been allowed to take the sling off at home for the past week, but still can’t use the right arm at all.

Left Side: Good old Lefty developed problems once I was forced to rely on it exclusively and I ended up in physical therapy for it too. These are the only exercises that I’ve been allowed to do on the left for the past seven weeks (I do them everyday):

Three sets each:
Front and side raises – 5#
Scaption (thumb up) – 4#
Scaption (thumb down) – 3#
Rotator cuff exercises with resistance bands
DB curls – 10#
Kickbacks – 8#

The weight is a small fraction of what I had been doing – it’s barely maintenance.

OK, so this makes me a little lab, comparing maintenance exercise on one side with absolutely none on the other. Keep in mind that every other factor is the same on both sides – nutrition, sleep, vitamins, working out legs, amount of cardio etc. The only difference between L and R is lifting weights.

What’s the result?

My left side looks about the same as always. I still have arm definition and a pretty nice shoulder (if I do say so myself :o ). Fortunately, I've maintained what I had.

The right side didn’t fare as well. My muscles have atrophied to an absolutely amazing extent. :eek: There’s no shoulder cut, no arm definition. My arm looks straight, flabby, and skinny, with no curves or tightness. If you put your hand on my shoulder, all you feel is bone -- my shoulder bones are bumps and knobs sticking out. From the neck to shoulder on the R and L sides, I’m visibly asymmetrical, even with clothes on. My shoulder blade is jutting out of my back and it hurts when I lean on it. And there’s a nice blob of flab hanging over the side of my bra that isn’t there on the other side.

It might be my imagination, but I can FEEL the difference between the two sides, between having muscle and not having muscle. My left side feels as strong and powerful as ever – my right side feels like a wet noodle.

The good news is that it will all come back, according to the phycial therapists ... in six months to a year.

What’s the lesson here? Wow, do we lose it FAST! All that hard-earned muscle will disappear in a few short weeks if we don’t keep working just to maintain it. It’s not often that you can compare the two sides of your body and see what NOT working out will do to you! When I can so dramatically see the side-to-side comparison of working out vs. not working out, it makes the reason why we go to the gym day after day crystal clear.

Don’t let this happen to you!! :D


Mel
02-23-2006, 08:46 PM
:hug: I hope you can end your experiment soon. Being a lab rat is no fun.

This is a great example of what I tell all the women who join the gym and then proceed to tell me that they "don't want to get big." First, it's not so easy to get big, and if by some miracle you manage to build more muscle than you like, the solution is really easy...stop what you are doing and change workout tactics ;)

Mel

Ilene
02-23-2006, 09:57 PM
Wow, Meg, :hug: ... I can only IMAGINE how anxious you are to getting back into the swing of things, but don't don't do it too soon k? What an experience that has turned into an experiment this has been for you, quite unbelievable. But the upside is that muscle has a very good memory and I know you will get back into shape much faster than what you physical therapist says, because I do really think that she is talking of the average person, and we all know that you are above average physically!


2frustrated
02-24-2006, 03:35 AM
Youch! Poor Meg, thanks for the info, even if you did have to totally bust your shoulder up to get it ;)

:hug:

BethC
02-24-2006, 07:58 AM
Wow Meg! I'm glad to hear you're on the mend and that you're be able to begin again soon. :hug:

I hurt my shoulder in January and had to take it easy for a few weeks. It wasn't easy, but now I'm back to my routine, I'm just really careful!

4rabbit
02-24-2006, 08:02 AM
Hi Meg,
Just a note to say thank you for sharing this with us, and I think it is a lesson to us all.
On another note, this must feel pretty awfull for you, and I hope you'll be out of that sling soon. Be careful with what you have left !

Thanks again,
rabbit

holicanmc
02-24-2006, 11:05 AM
I had almost the exact same experience only with my left leg instead of shoulder/arm. I was on crutches with an immobilizer on for a few weeks after tearing a bunch of stuff in my knee. I remember being completely amazed at how fast the muscles, specifically my quad, just disappeared. My leg turned into jelly. The best part about losing muscle in one leg was occassionally I would just fall flat on my face :D . After the immobilizer came off but before the muscle built back up I would be walking and my knee would involuntarily bend when I put weight on it, I found the situation quite funny, especially when it was in front of others. Also, after years of favoring my right leg for all activities it appears I may have some problems with that one now. My good leg has become my bad leg and vice versa, so watch out for that.

Anyway, just wanted to further confirm Meg's experiment, not that it needed any confirmation. And BTW, good luck with the rebuilding and try not to push yourself *too* hard.

sf40
02-24-2006, 11:12 AM
WOW! That big of a change in just seven weeks?!? :fr:

Thanks for sharing, though you learned it through personal experience. I hope you get the use of your right arm back soon.