Ideal Protein Diet - IP Chocolate Drink Alternative




View Full Version : IP Chocolate Drink Alternative


BrittStar027
01-07-2013, 10:58 PM
My favorite packet on IP was always the chocolate drink. After a while, the only things i got were boxes of the chocolate drink and some bars for a treat. I'm attempting IP again with alternatives and have yet to find something that comes close. Any suggestions? I've tried Isopure (gagged it down), EAS Advantedge (do-able), and Atkins (the best yet). I REALLY don't want to go back to my clinic because they're going to make me pay the joining fee again. Some people have mentioned ordering IP packets online, any suggestions for that (i might break down and just get some chocolate drinks)? OR any alternative chocolate drink suggestions that i haven't tried?


Tziri
01-07-2013, 11:07 PM
http://www.plainprotein.com for the actual IP products.

Check out the different chocolate drinks on http://www.nashuanutrition.com
I haven't tried any of those yet, but I know other people on here have.

BrittStar027
01-07-2013, 11:16 PM
Thank you!!! I've been trying to use alternatives to save money, but i really miss the IP chocolate drink and have been curious about some of the new products. I might break down and buy a box as a treat.


smjohnso69
01-07-2013, 11:52 PM
I have ordered Healthsmart Chocorite Chocolate Brownie Fudge shake and the peanut butter flavor from http://www4.netrition.com/healthsmart_chocolite_protein_shakes.html. Sometimes I use a scoop of each & tastes like peanut butter cup. They are kind of high protein, but absolutely taste wonderful and are $11.79 per bag.
Nutrition Facts
Serving Size: 2 Scoops (38g)
Servings Per Container: about 11

Amount
Per Serving % Daily
Value*

Total Calories 150

Calories From Fat 20

Total Fat 3 g 5%

Saturated Fat 1.5 g 8%

Trans Fat 0 g

Cholesterol 0 mg 0%

Sodium 40 mg 2%

Total Carbohydrates 8 g 3%

Dietary Fiber 5 g 20%

Sugars 0 g

Show Net Carbs

Protein 24 g

Vitamin A 15%

infoplease
01-08-2013, 02:04 AM
Sadly, I have not yet found a substitute and will likely order the real thing on line for a treat (even in maintenance!). I've grown to like drinking it cold with crushed ice; I used it for hot chocolate for over 6 months prior.

What doesn't even come close in taste: anything with stevia (too sweet), Synthrax (which a lot of people like), HealthWise (don't get me started), Joe Robb (whey or egg), Betty Lou...

Right now I committed to a big container of Market Pantry (Target) mix. It dissolves completely (doesn't get that thickness that IP has) and tastes kind of off, but it is $18 for 25 servings, is a little higher in protein (25g) and calories (150) while low in carbs (5g/1g fiber) and sugars plus sweetened with acesulfame potassium and sucralose. I'm kind of getting used to it but still prefer the IP.

I've even googled the ingredients list hoping I could find something else with the same ingredients. Trying to figure out which company makes it, but no luck. So frustrating!

patns
01-08-2013, 02:17 AM
Did you try Premier Nutrition ones at Costco? They taste close to the IP ready to drink ones to me. Other people say they don't taste the same.

I don't know where you are located. If by chance you are in Canada the ones at the Dr Berenstien clinics are the same ones as IP but much cheaper.

infoplease
01-08-2013, 02:26 AM
Don't know about the OP, but I never liked the ready-to-drink ones nearly as much as the drink mix.

SassyGirl424
01-08-2013, 07:05 AM
Don't know about the OP, but I never liked the ready-to-drink ones nearly as much as the drink mix.

I also have not found a RTD that I like as much. I even tried putting the RTDs in a blender with some ice, to kind of aerate them a little, and even added some extra cocoa to them....drinkable, but not the same.

I am waiting for my Nashua order with sample of some of the Syntrax Nectar flavors....keep hoping for a good substitute. We do not have Costco near us, or I'd be in there getting the Premier Nutrition.

Good luck with the search. Keep us posted with your findings.

karcher
01-08-2013, 08:36 AM
I use the Pure Protein Chocolate Frosty as a more affordable shake mix. It is lower in carbs than the IP and does not count as restricted. It's really good. 25g of Protein, 3g carbs. The vanilla one from Pure Protein I didn't like but I use the chocolate almost every day!

I have also ordered genuine IP products from www.plainprotein.com
If you wanted to try official check out joining Ideal-to-go (much cheaper than a clinic and they sell the WF products!)

Hope this helps!!!! You can do it :)

ragdoll74
01-08-2013, 09:42 AM
I have the protithin hot chocolate 2 times a day. Absolutely love it! It's the closest thing I could find to the IP chocolate drink packet. I order from Nashua.

Whenever someone comes into my office at work while I am drinking it they always comment on how good it smells.

brunette8706
01-08-2013, 09:53 AM
Sadly, I have not yet found a substitute and will likely order the real thing on line for a treat (even in maintenance!). I've grown to like drinking it cold with crushed ice; I used it for hot chocolate for over 6 months prior.

What doesn't even come close in taste: anything with stevia (too sweet), Synthrax (which a lot of people like), HealthWise (don't get me started), Joe Robb (whey or egg), Betty Lou...

Right now I committed to a big container of Market Pantry (Target) mix. It dissolves completely (doesn't get that thickness that IP has) and tastes kind of off, but it is $18 for 25 servings, is a little higher in protein (25g) and calories (150) while low in carbs (5g/1g fiber) and sugars plus sweetened with acesulfame potassium and sucralose. I'm kind of getting used to it but still prefer the IP.

I've even googled the ingredients list hoping I could find something else with the same ingredients. Trying to figure out which company makes it, but no luck. So frustrating!

*
Hi there! What is the name of the chocolate drink from Target? Market Pantry?

Here is one on sale at Target Pure Protein!

http://www.target.com/p/pure-protein-frosty-chocolate-whey-protein-powder-2-lbs/-/A-12634508

evepet
01-08-2013, 09:59 AM
I've used a few different protein powders over the past months, but the line I like the best is ChocoRite. I notice that someone else mentioned it above. Each suggested serving is 24proteins, so I just use 1.5 scoops/shake.

I've most recently been using ChocoRite's Chocolate Supreme. So far, the best substitute I've found for IP's chocolate drink. (Which I also loved). It heats up well in the microwave to make a nice hot chocolate drink. I've also been using ChocoRite's Cappuccino shakemix for months. It makes a good substitute for IP's cappuccino, when blended into fresh decaf coffee.

usmcvet
01-08-2013, 10:08 AM
I have the protithin hot chocolate 2 times a day. Absolutely love it! It's the closest thing I could find to the IP chocolate drink packet. I order from Nashua.

Whenever someone comes into my office at work while I am drinking it they always comment on how good it smells.

I have a bucket of this, it is very close and for the price worth it. I do miss the IP chocolate packets the most. They get really frothy and taste delicious. The protithin is good and I think it's closer to a buck a serving.

I bought a 4 pack of the Pure Protein shakes the other day at WalMart, they're pretty good and I would buy them again.

BrittStar027
01-08-2013, 09:40 PM
I was given the name of a site that sells IP products at a discounted rate ($24.99 per box) and turned onto Proti-Diet products. A few of you have mentioned that they really like the Proti-Diet chocolate shakes and hot chocolate. I've been burned so many times when buying alternatives, and i'm reluctant to order it. Honestly, how close is it to iP???

Lizzy63
01-08-2013, 10:09 PM
I like the Pure Protein frosty chocolate RTD.

AnnaBoBanna
01-08-2013, 10:40 PM
I like the Pure Protein frosty chocolate RTD.

Me too! I really enjoy it. I actually just found some coupons off ebay for Pure Protein products (bars, RTD, powders) $1 and $2 off. When I get them, I am going to stock up!

Sinky2007
01-10-2013, 12:17 AM
Hi Ladies,
I am new to this site. I just bought alternative and am very nervous. I bought pure protein chocolate drink and don't like it. Are you mixing with water? What vitamins are you using? I think I'm going to take my IP vitamins to GNC and see if they can find an alternative.
Any help would be great.

scorbett1103
01-10-2013, 01:19 AM
Hi Ladies,
I am new to this site. I just bought alternative and am very nervous. I bought pure protein chocolate drink and don't like it. Are you mixing with water? What vitamins are you using? I think I'm going to take my IP vitamins to GNC and see if they can find an alternative.
Any help would be great.

If you are buying powdered drink mixes, water is pretty much the only thing you can mix it with on IP, or black coffee. Some of the shake mixes suggest that you mix with milk, and mixing with water would give it a thinner consistency and taste. Try using a little less water - that's what I do with Syntrax drink mixes, 8oz water makes them too thin for my taste but 6-7 oz works well for me.

mpstaton
01-13-2013, 05:50 PM
My wife and I just started on 1/2/13 and have been having two Proti-Diet chocolate shakes each day. They are really good and available from NashuaNutrition.

BrittStar027
01-13-2013, 06:18 PM
My ProtiDiet order came in on Friday, and i LOVE their chocolate drink! So happy you guys turned me on to ProtiDiet. Their hot chocolate, blueberry pancakes and chocolate drink are great!

amkgraham
02-17-2014, 06:27 PM
I am considering purchasing some of the Plain Protein drinks from the link that I saw in this thread earlier...similar to Ideal Protein but less costly.

http://www.plainprotein.com/drinks/chocolate-drink/pudding-mix/

BrittStar027 - what are some other flavors that you enjoyed from that website? I'd love to hear more before I purchase some.

mars735
02-17-2014, 06:35 PM
I too was a big fan of IP rtd chocolate. I like Cytosport's Muscle Milk Lite & Muscle milk sugar free. They are similar to one another but the sugar free is most like IP both in taste and macronutrient profile. I think you can get them pretty cheaply at Vitacost.com, also Vitamin Shoppe, GNC, and I've been seeing them at big chain grocery & pharmacies. Here on the west coast, that would be Safeway & Rite Aid, maybe CVS. The vanilla flavor is good, too.

Bellamack
02-17-2014, 06:50 PM
I use the Pure Protein Chocolate Frosty as a more affordable shake mix. It is lower in carbs than the IP and does not count as restricted. It's really good. 25g of Protein, 3g carbs. The vanilla one from Pure Protein I didn't like but I use the chocolate almost every day!

I have also ordered genuine IP products from www.plainprotein.com
If you wanted to try official check out joining Ideal-to-go (much cheaper than a clinic and they sell the WF products!)

Hope this helps!!!! You can do it :)

You can no longer get IP products on line.

vtcowgirl
02-17-2014, 08:06 PM
I think the premier protein drinks are almost exactly the same in flavor and consistency. And... $24.99 for 18 at Costco!