Weight Loss Support - why does my scale do this?




View Full Version : why does my scale do this?


tubolard
10-19-2012, 09:50 AM
I get on my scale it shows 213.2, I get on again it shows 215.6 I get on again, it shows 210, I get on again it show 214.8 etc etc. I weigh three times and go with the number I see the most often. How is it possible to have so many different numbers like that within a minute or two? I changed batteries, same thing. This is a brand new scale but my old one did it too, hence the new scale. I weigh in the same spot, feet in same position, arms in same position so what happens? :?:


TripSwitch
10-19-2012, 10:09 AM
You're not alone... This seems to happen to me a lot with digital scales as well... I like to think that it's just being "temperamental" because it knows how crazy it makes me :)

But in all seriousness... In my experience a good quality old fashioned scale with just a dial with numbers doesn't do that... So that's what I do to save my sanity in that sort of situation...

Missy Krissy
10-19-2012, 10:16 AM
This is why I only weigh myself once in the morning. Maybe our scales do this because they're insulted that we don't believe what they tell us the first time - it's like we're calling them liars.


joefla70
10-19-2012, 10:40 AM
My scale does this too! I have the WW glass digital scale. I find that if I typically step on and off the scale about 6 times and usually there is one number that will come up 3 times. I pick that number.

tubolard
10-19-2012, 10:55 AM
My scale does this too! I have the WW glass digital scale. I find that if I typically step on and off the scale about 6 times and usually there is one number that will come up 3 times. I pick that number.

That's exactly what I do, but some days the same number doesn't come up more than once. Maybe I will go back to my old dial scale like TripSwitch suggested.

XLMuffnTop
10-19-2012, 10:57 AM
My old digital scale did that regardless of new batteries. I went down to Walmart and got another for about $25. I don't care how often I get off and back on, that thing stays the same. The brand is Health O Meter if you're interested.

Garnet2727
10-19-2012, 10:58 AM
That is why I got rid of my digital scale. I now have an old fashioned balance beam scale that is accurate to a quarter of a pound. Yes, it's big but its accuracy has certainly settled me down.

novangel
10-19-2012, 11:09 AM
Mine's a digital which has been pretty accurate but I'm only allowed one weigh in per day. If I get back on within minutes taking clothes on and off (just for giggles) it will tell me the same exact number to the ounce. It cuts me off after one weigh in. Very rude scale.

So one weigh in, naked. I have to play by its rules. :lol: Needless to say I hate that damn thing.

joefla70
10-19-2012, 11:23 AM
Mine's a digital which has been pretty accurate but I'm only allowed one weigh in per day. If I get back on within minutes taking clothes on and off (just for giggles) it will tell me the same exact number to the ounce. It cuts me off after one weigh in. Very rude scale.

So one weigh in, naked. I have to play by its rules. :lol: Needless to say I hate that damn thing.

Oh, that would drive me crazy. I'm obsessed with weighing. Even though I have an "official" weekly weigh-in, I weigh myself every day -- and several times throughout the day!

LebenAlles
10-19-2012, 11:32 AM
I had the same issue...went through two scales (one of them the WW glass scale) before getting the EatSmart Precision scale. It has been awesome. I did the mega test on it by taking it around to three different hard surfaces, recalibrating every time (which is a nice feature that it has) and it gave me a very consistent weigh in with difference of only .4 lbs.

You have to keep in mind that every time you move or bump the scale, it needs to be recalibrated. So having one that can easily do that is a plus. Read the reviews for the EatSmart on amazon...it's worth it for the 'scale peace of mind' in my opinion!

gailr42
10-19-2012, 11:44 AM
Like Garnet, I invested in a balance scale which I keep in my living room. LOL. I can't close the bathroom door if I keep it in there.

Yes, it's big, but there are no more questions. I still weigh myself too much, but it doesn't upset me anymore.

Arctic Mama
10-19-2012, 01:41 PM
I have a Tanita digital scale that is eight years old, and thought it can register different numbers each time I step on it, the deviation is generally only +- .2 pounds off the first input. It's normal for digital scales as things like weight shifts or having our feet in a slightly different spot can cause a different pressure to register, but a good scale will generally have smaller than larger deviations. I've been super happy with mine, and its batteries have been changed maybe four times in the span we've owned it.

Desiderata
10-19-2012, 01:46 PM
Are you sure the spot on the floor is completely level? Even if it's a hard surface, your floor may not be 100% level. (I moved into a 70-year old house a few months ago and had 'fun' dragging my scale around, looking for an actually level spot on the floor.)

Home Depot and Lowes sell tools called levels -- basically thick-looking rulers with small vials of liquid tilted in the center. You place it along an object and look if the air bubble in the vials is actually centered to determine if something is truly level.

tubolard
10-19-2012, 01:55 PM
Are you sure the spot on the floor is completely level? Even if it's a hard surface, your floor may not be 100% level. (I moved into a 70-year old house a few months ago and had 'fun' dragging my scale around, looking for an actually level spot on the floor.)

Home Depot and Lowes sell tools called levels -- basically thick-looking rulers with small vials of liquid tilted in the center. You place it along an object and look if the air bubble in the vials is actually centered to determine if something is truly level.

I never thought about checking that! I highly doubt my floors are level. My house is at least 40 years old, made of at least second hand materials (We found built in shelves made of old signs with ads on the back of them, obviously reused boards, etc) and sits on pretty damp ground so i am sure it has settled crooked. If i dropped a marble I bet that thing would roll around all through the house and never stop, lol.

Psyence
10-19-2012, 05:23 PM
I have the WW glass scales as well and they do this to me all the time. Get so pleased when I step on them and they say I've lost like 2lbs overnight, then step on them again and I've gained! Sometimes i've no idea which number to take since they're never the same.

It's definitely the uneven floor though. I used to live in a modern flat with a concreted bathroom floor (it was completely solid anyway!) and they were always spot on, now living in a Victorian house with creaky wooden floorboards and my scales are unreliable!

tubolard
10-19-2012, 10:08 PM
I checked my floor and it is level (I am in shock) so I took the new scales back. I am just going to go with my dial type scales.

juliastl27
10-20-2012, 12:45 AM
I have the WW glass scales as well and they do this to me all the time.!

i have one of these too and i HATE it. ive owned 2 or 3 in my life and i have no idea why i buy them. its like i have a different kind for a while and i forget how much i hate WW scales. youd think that a company marketing to dieters would have less crappy scales, also the scales "memory" has made me want to throw it out the window about 500 times.

MrsTryingAgain
10-20-2012, 12:54 AM
This is what I do. Before I weigh, I make sure it's zeroed out...set on zero. Scale firmly on the floor, not on carpet.
Always weigh myself on the same day of the week & first thing in the morning. I have a "ritual" when I'm on my program. I weigh & measure myself each Sunday morning. I generally don't work on Sunday, so I have time to weigh & measure without being rushed. I always have my pen & calendar close at hand so I don't have to re-weigh or re-measure.
If nothing more, it helps me be accountable because I KNOW Sunday is coming. Am I doing what I can to make it a "happier" day off. If not, I don't beat myself up, I just make a vow to do better for the next Sunday.