Exercise! - Earbuds that stay in place?




View Full Version : Earbuds that stay in place?


julesp313
03-31-2011, 04:21 PM
I have small ears (the only part of me that is small!) and most earbuds slip out when I get sweaty. I currently have a pair that loop over my ears, and they stay sort of in place, but once the sweat gets in the way - and it invariably does every single time I work out - they start to slide out of my ears. I've tried a few different designs but not found anything great yet. I only use them in the gym but I'm happy to spend a decent amount on a pair that truly STAYS in my difficult ears! Any suggestions are most appreciated!


iriswhispers
03-31-2011, 04:28 PM
I have the same problem and I have taken to using old-school headphones instead of ear buds most of the time. I just go crazy constantly adjusting or re-inserting the ear buds otherwise!

julesp313
03-31-2011, 04:38 PM
My only concern with the old-style headphones is just how nasty they would get with my sweatiness! I guess as long as they don't have the foam covers on them, they may be OK. Why can't companies make really well-fitting sports earbuds that are reasonably priced, easy to find, and have sweat-repelling magic? :)


iriswhispers
03-31-2011, 04:41 PM
You can usually take the foam covers off and wash/replace them. But yeah... it can get kind of gross! I bet someone makes specialty ear buds for small ears, but who knows how to find them?

asweetchicagogirl1
03-31-2011, 04:54 PM
I love the Skullcandy earbuds...they are a bit pricy but stay put. Each package comes with three different size rubber-like things that go over the actual ear bud (one of which is really small and might work for you).

Andrbeck
03-31-2011, 04:55 PM
I have the same problem it drives me nuts! I feel like its always just one side falling out which throws off my rhythm. I thought about just buying the old fashioned ones but had the same concern about the foam getting gross. And when you try to take them off it seems like the foam always rips. I think they make plastic covered ones.. those would be easy to clean.

Snoofie
03-31-2011, 05:29 PM
I second the Skullcandy love! I had a pair once and they were *awesome*. I'm in need of a new pair now (I have the small ear issue myself *L*) and they're going to be Skullcandy. I've never had a pair that were a good as those.

souvenirdarling
03-31-2011, 05:32 PM
I love inner-ear earphones. I also have small ears and use the smallest rubber piece. Skullcandy makes them, but so do other brands.

NaturalStupidit
03-31-2011, 07:07 PM
I have the same problem! I just wound up getting those big, DJ headphones that basically fit over your ear. They get sweaty but I just make sure to wipe them down with disinfectant and spray with Lysol.

thatgirl76
03-31-2011, 07:15 PM
Ugh, so glad you asked about this! I almost fell off my treadmill the other day trying to keep mine in.

Gonna have to try Skullcandy

JenMusic
03-31-2011, 08:45 PM
I have small ears (the ear canal part, at least!) and love, love, LOVE my Shure E3C in-ears. I've been using them since 2005. They come with both foam, soft rubber, and hard rubber ear "plugs," so you can figure out what works best for you. I bought mine on Amazon for around $80 and they were worth every penny. In fact, about a year after I got them, one of the wire leads started to split - I'm pretty sure it was because I was wearing them in freezing temps for long periods of time - and they were replaced for free. :) Can't beat that!

Also, the sound is amazing!

Lauren201
03-31-2011, 09:13 PM
I love the Skullcandy earbuds...they are a bit pricy but stay put. Each package comes with three different size rubber-like things that go over the actual ear bud (one of which is really small and might work for you).

Skullcandy was what I was going to recommend! They are so awesome. I love mine.

julesp313
03-31-2011, 09:46 PM
SweetChicago, Snoofie, LaurenI've tried Skullcandy - they don't stay in. I mean, I tried all three sizes of the "covers" for the earbuds, but every single damn time, the left one falls out when I get sweaty. I tend to sweat a lot on my head and it drips into my ears... gross, huh? Maybe I'm using the wrong Skullcandy ones? I don't know... I'm just so frustrated with my seemingly never-ending quest for these bloody things! And I shove those buds as far into the ear as I can get it... maybe there's a trick to sticking these buds into the ear to make 'em stay?

Andrbeck - I really don't fancy the idea of ones on the outside of my ears... I truly drip sweat into my ears and I think it would just be a nasty damp foamy mess after a half hour! But I'm glad it's not just me who's suffering!

Souvenir - I have the in-ear ones. I have probably 10 pairs of the things... all with various shapes and sizes of covers, various hooks over the ears... NONE of which stay in place! I am a freak of nature, I think... :)

Natural - I don't really like the over-ear ones. Maybe it's my downfall... :)

JenMusic - I'd heard of Shure from a friend of mine who's in music production, but I am so reluctant to spend that sort of money on yet another set of earbuds that may or may not stay in place. Maybe I can find a retailer that has a 30 day return policy, though part of me is kind of skeeved out at the idea of trying them and returning them after I've sweated all over them! I guess you can clean them with some sort of sanitizer.

I've got some Bose in-ear buds that work for non-workouts, but even those don't stay in - and again, they came with three sizes of covers and none of them stay in place. But when I'm not working out, the sound quality is amazing.

This is going to become my mission, I tell you... Right now I have some $25 ones from Target, that I think are Nike, and they're OK. They sort of stay in my ear, as long as every 10 minutes I take them out, wipe them, wipe my ear, and stick 'em back in. Annoying and I usually stumble like a crazy on the treadmill while I do it...

Keep the suggestions coming! I swear I'm not trying to be negative and shoot down every person's idea, it's just I've struggled with this for probably a few years and I welcome anyone's opinion on something I may not have yet tried!

JenMusic
03-31-2011, 09:53 PM
Hmmmm . . . I see what you mean.

When I put mine in, I use the opposite hand to pull on the top of my ear, then twisting and putting the earbud in at the same time. Make sense? Probably not :), but you can find better explantions online.

The other thing I like about the Shure is that the wires go behind your ears, down your back. I think that helps them stay in.

All that being said, you may just have ears that make it really hard to keep earbuds in. :(

julesp313
03-31-2011, 10:06 PM
Jen - are yours the noise-cancelling ones? I can't find EC-3 on Amazon but there are a bunch of Shures to choose from. I like the idea of the wire going behind the ear - that would be much safer given my clutziness on the cardio machines. I do think my ears are just funky and not in a good way!

JenMusic
03-31-2011, 10:40 PM
I got mine so long ago, so I don't remember if they were specifically called "noise-cancelling." I just checked on Amazon and it looks like they've been discontinued, which is a bummer. Looking on the Shure website, they've been replaced with a more expensive line. :(

http://store.shure.com/store/shure/en_US/pd/productID.121026300

The list price is $120, but doing a quick search online I found some much cheaper.

I can't talk about thi specific model, though. Sorry. But, FWIW, I would go with Shure again next time I need to get earbuds.

julesp313
04-01-2011, 03:44 PM
Just found a website that sells waterproof earbuds - H2o audio - and I'm thinking waterproof might be good. If you can swim in them - Michael Phelps is a spokesperson - surely they can withstand my sweaty head! I may well give them a try and see - they are in-ear buds and come with five sizes of covers so it sounds like it might be even more flexible than the ones that come with three. Such a challenge! :)

JenMusic
04-01-2011, 04:07 PM
PLEASE update the thread when you get them, and let us know how you like them! I might be in the market one day. :)

Alenna 52
04-02-2011, 09:09 PM
I had the same problem for years - I tried so many types, I have a whole drawer full of them, including some pricy Bose types, which always seem to slip out of my ears while running. The ones I like best now for running (outdoors) are the Philips "Premium Sound" earhook headphones. They don't come out because they hook over the back of your ears. Indoors on the treadmill I like "noise cancelling" headphones to cut the sound of the treadmill.

Resolute
04-03-2011, 10:28 AM
Koss portapros, not earbuds :yuck: still the best mobile headphones i've ever had, they've been making them for over 25 years, thats how good they are. :)

Can't speak for looks but wear a snug cap over them and they are solid in place and partly hidden, but who cares when you are getting your sweat on ? :)

julesp313
04-05-2011, 09:44 PM
Jen - they're en route! I'll definitely post after I've used them a few times and give an expert review. :)

Alenna - the Phillips are the ones I have now. They do OK as in they don't fall out of my ears, but once the sweat gets going, they do slip somewhat so I lose the decent sound. And it's just annoying to have to take them out, wipe my ear, wipe the earbud, stick them back in, and try not to fall on the treadmill while doing that! Maybe I'm just too picky - I don't know anyone else IRL who has such issues!

Resolute - I really don't like over the ear phones, though I'm sure they would resolve the slipping out of the ear issue! I am constantly shoving my hair back from my face, so a headband-type set of phones would bother me as I can't get my hair back (it's not long enough to put up or tie back). Plus there's the sweat factor - the bigger earphones, I imagine, would get nasty with all the sweat collecting under them. Like I said, though, I may just be far too picky and difficult for my own damn good!

julesp313
04-08-2011, 01:49 PM
OK, first impressions of the new earbuds - awesome. Seriously. They came with five sizes of covers, and it turns out the mediums - which is what were "installed" - are perfect. I did an hour on a spin bike today and I soaked through my shirt and a towel, and they didn't move once. I think the combination of the various size buds plus the way they sit in my ear makes them a great solution for me. If anyone is interested, the brand is H20 Audio, I got the Surge 2G model, and paid $28 on Amazon. The retail is $50. They are completely waterproof and you can even swim in them, assuming you have a waterproof case for your iPod or whatever!

aimeebell
04-11-2011, 12:30 AM
My standard earbuds that came with my Ipod have been driving me nuts for three years, but thought it would be the same issue with all earbuds and never even looked for others. On the suggestion of many, I bought Skull Candy earbuds yesterday, popped on the smallest size, and ran for 50 minutes without them coming out once. $10 well spent!