Personally, I've had much more success with my bottom and thighs on the treadmill. I have a lot of experience with the elliptical, the stair stepper and the treadmill. I've used each individually for an extended period of time. I've evaluated my body throughout the time that I have used each machine, and for me the treadmill proved to be the most effective by far.
I have to qualify that, though. You can't target fat loss. Any of these machines will help you to lose fast, and that fat will come off of your body where it is genetically programmed to be lost. The fact that you are working your butt and legs does not mean that the fat in those places is being targeted specifically.
What I have found with the treadmill is that I like the shape that is left behind after fat loss. I think the treadmill has shaped my lower half better than the other machines.
BTW, I don't know if you were holding on to the elliptical the whole time or just long enough to get your heart rate, but you shouldn't hold on to any of the equipment when you are working out (unless of course your elliptical is designed for arm movement). It lowers your calorie burn because you are not working your body as hard.
Last edited by Petite Powerhouse; 01-18-2011 at 12:47 PM.
|