100 lb. Club - Is Weighing In Every Day Good??




View Full Version : Is Weighing In Every Day Good??


clurrrburrr
01-17-2011, 04:24 PM
I'm torn right now between doing daily weigh-ins (to catch myself early if I'm doing something wrong) and weekly ones, as WW calls for.

I heard from a therapist once that daily weigh-ins can lead to emotional stress eating.

What do you guys think? Is it good, or will it hurt in the long run?


DisgruntledOne
01-17-2011, 04:34 PM
it all depends on who you are. Some people here do it everyday some people don't. I now realize I am the later. It causes me alot of distress. So the battery in my scales are two floors down from where my scale is. Once a month they will meet up.

seagirl
01-17-2011, 04:37 PM
I like daily weighing, not because it will catch me doing something wrong, but because it helps me see that there can be daily fluctuations even when the general trend is downward. I'm on WW and weigh daily, but WW logs my weight once a week.


Gamecockgrrl
01-17-2011, 04:41 PM
I weigh in everyday, but it's with the understanding that weight fluctuates throughout the day, and over the course of a week. While I do weigh everyday, it's not consistent and I don't track it. I only count my Sunday weight because I make sure to be consistent with the time of day. Mostly, I weigh everyday as sort of a scientific experiment with what I have eaten the day before. I do this because I'm just starting out and I'm trying to get a gauge on what is working and what isn't. For example: this morning, I weighed one pound more than yesterday (my official weigh day). I wanted to see how the diet soda I had yesterday affected me, and I realize I should limit myself to one a week instead of 4! I will probably skip weighing daily the longer I'm in this and the more familiar I get with what's working.

OhMyDogs
01-17-2011, 04:45 PM
I WANT to be a weekly weigher, but I keep managing to step on the scale (I have no scale will-power apparently). So after my official weigh in tomorrow, I'm going to ask my husband to put the battery away for me, and to not give it back for 1 week....this will be my trial. I will have done 1 week of daily weigh ins, and one week where I don't even look at the scale to see which suits me better.

MindiV
01-17-2011, 04:48 PM
When I was actively losing, I would weigh in once a week. Once I hit maintenance I started every day, and it has really opened my eyes to fluctuations and how my body reacts when I eat certain things.

Shmead
01-17-2011, 04:56 PM
I weigh daily because if I weighed once a week, I'd build up crazy expectations and be disappointed. This way I can see the overall trend. I keep an excel spreadsheet that tracks my 7 day average, so even if I bounce up for a day or two, I can see that the overall trend is down.

Loving Me
01-17-2011, 04:56 PM
The first half of my weight loss journey I weighed once a week on a Friday am. The second half I moved to daily weigh ins but as I got closer to goal this started turning into a bad idea.
Although I knew my body fluctuated daily, it got to the point where I really couldn't handle it, two out of three weigh ins left me in a real down mood for the rest of the day. So as of last week I've gone back to weekly weigh ins. Got weighed last Friday and trying to wait til this Friday before I weigh again. Will see how that goes...

lostangel05
01-17-2011, 04:58 PM
I read online that people who weighed daily lost 12 pounds, where people who weighed weekly only lost 6. I weigh first thing every morning. But, as with most things, you gotta choose what works best for you.

TooManyDimples
01-17-2011, 05:01 PM
I'm a weekly weigher. I can't handle the daily shifts even if I know the reason for an upward one. I'm much happier only seeing it once a week. You could always try weighing everyday, if you can handle it, that's great, if not you can move to weekly.

duckyyellowfeet
01-17-2011, 05:41 PM
I'm a weekly weigher right now because the battery is dead in my scale so I'm only being weighed in at my WW meetings.
Once i'm not so broke, I'm going back to daily weighing. I know my weight changes daily and I would like to go back to tracking those changes.

I also find it keeps me more realistic about my weight. Right now, I have the "its 4pm, I have clothes on, i ate a ton today" excuses

sept15lija
01-17-2011, 06:43 PM
I weigh daily. It works for me - I like seeing what happens day to day. Like another poster mentioned, I think if I weighed weekly I'd build up expectation too, and then possibly be disappointed.

nickyj
01-17-2011, 06:58 PM
I dont own A scale, but I weigh every time I go to the gym. When we had a scale in the house, I obsessed, and it caused me to stop working out because I wasnt losing anything. Now I want to weigh once a week, but, it pretty much turns into a daily thing because I cant help myself. Its hard on me though, becauseI feel like nothing is happining, even though I lost 6 pounds in two weeks.

lawchick29
01-17-2011, 06:58 PM
I weigh in several times a week but try not to do the daily weigh-in. I just started the IP diet and was really curious my first week so found myself stepping on it more than I did when I was on WW. The body fluctuates so much it can really play tricks on your mind doing it too often but that's just my opinion. Good Luck!:carrot:

carter
01-17-2011, 07:06 PM
I have to weigh every day.

I am a major procrastinator in every aspect of my life and it's too easy for me to fool myself into thinking if I slack off on something now I have time to make it up later.

So when I used to go to Weight Watchers some years ago, it was very hard not to overeat after my meeting because I had a WHOLE WEEK until I was going to be weighed again in which to make up for overeating that one day. Weighing every day prevents me from playing that game.

Weighing every day lets me see, claim, and celebrate the fluctuations downward as well as the fluctuations upward. ;) I keep track of my "current low" even though on any particular day my weight might be a pound or two up from that current low. And it's very helpful to me to see all the fluctuations, start to learn my body's patterns.

mdchick88
01-17-2011, 07:15 PM
It definitely depends on you - if you're someone who will get really upset by daily fluctuations, then once a week is probably best.

I weigh in every day, just because I can't help it! Honestly, I weigh at least 10 times a day, which is wayyy excessive, but like OhMyDogs, I have no scale willpower! My original plan was to weigh daily at first, and once I got on a eating/exercise plan that worked, I would switch to weekly. But daily weighing has made me more accountable, I think.

twinmommaplusone
01-17-2011, 07:24 PM
I used to weigh myself 3x daily,lmao. Now once a day is really working for me. I fluctuate grandly so I can see where only once a weekly could leave me disturbed and likely frustrated. Once Daily I recognize what foods I eat that could cause me to bloat-water retain etc. GL in YOUR choice!

caryesings
01-17-2011, 07:31 PM
I think it truly depends on your personality. I attribute a big part of my success to NOT weighing in at all for first 72 days of my plan and only once a month since. It was important to me to follow my plan, not react to the scale.

FitGirlyGirl
01-17-2011, 07:31 PM
It really depends on the individual. I weigh in daily for 2 major reasons.

1. If I don't do it daily and try weekly instead then I am the type of person to forget a week and let that turn to 2 and then it's months and things go badly from there.

2. If I weigh myself daily then I know I don't do my only weigh in for the week on a bad day.

I do have 1 day that is official, currently Tuesday, for my body bugg. I count that weight even if it is a bad day, but at least I will know that it was just a bad day.

ThinningVegan
01-17-2011, 08:38 PM
I also find that daily weigh in's help me. I also know that I weigh in daily with the knowledge that the number will fluctuate. It can change greatly from day to day depending on a lot of different causes and I also think that it will help to see patterns and get to know more about how my body works in conjunction with how I am eating and working out. It keeps me accountable.

pnkrckpixikat
01-17-2011, 09:01 PM
I have my weekly 'official' weigh in that i use for my tickers and for the challenges I'm in, but I tend to weigh every day or two or more depending on when the mood strikes. sometimes I'll go the whole week without weighing in and sometimes i'll weigh in more then once in a day

Eliana
01-17-2011, 09:09 PM
I weigh daily because if I weighed once a week, I'd build up crazy expectations and be disappointed. This way I can see the overall trend. I keep an excel spreadsheet that tracks my 7 day average, so even if I bounce up for a day or two, I can see that the overall trend is down.

Me too. Surely I worked hard enough this week to drop 9 pounds, right? :dizzy:

Emme
01-17-2011, 09:09 PM
I like to weigh in daily. I can't do it once a week because not seeing the scale for a week makes me think that I can overeat since I'll have time to work it off before my next weight in. Not good.

Shmead
01-17-2011, 09:43 PM
Me too. Surely I worked hard enough this week to drop 9 pounds, right? :dizzy:

Followed by "Oh no, only two pounds! I suck!" Amazing how everything is relative.

sem1223
01-17-2011, 11:48 PM
I also like to weigh everyday. I may be a little obsessed but I love to watch and journal my daily weight. I set small ten pound goals and the closer and closer I get the more excited I get. I work out to jillian michaels. Im doing jumping jacks Saying Bikini, Bikini!!!

shannonmb
01-18-2011, 07:42 AM
It's such an individual thing. For my first 60 or so pounds, I was weighing monthly. That worked really well for me with so much to lose, it was nice to see a pretty substantial loss every time I got on the scale. Now I've moved to weekly so I can get a good idea if things need to be tweaked as I go. I don't think I could ever be happy with weighing daily on the way down, too much of a head game! But maybe once I'm closer to maintenance it won't bother me as much. Only YOU can figure out what works for you, so do some experimenting!

ladyfyre
01-18-2011, 08:06 AM
I weigh everyday, a few times a day. I wish I didn't have to, but it also allows me to see the fluctuations throughout the day and week. So if I haven't lost a lot of weight for my weekly weigh, I don't get too discouraged because I might just be on an up fluctuation

krampus
01-18-2011, 08:07 AM
I weigh daily. It's just built into my routine. I get up, pee, strip down to my underwear, and weigh. I also like to weigh after working out before eating dinner to see where I am.

lisanovak
01-18-2011, 09:56 AM
I weigh daily also. I posted a piece of paper on the inside of my bathroom cabinet with the days of the week on it. Every morning I pee, get on the scale and write down the weight. It helps me to see where I am at. I also do Weight Watchers, but I weigh in on Monday evenings, and I always weigh more at night than in the morning. So, it just makes me feel a bit better about where I am at.

brenbray06
01-18-2011, 12:04 PM
I have in the past weighed myself daily but I found it to be a bad thing for me. I now am weighing in weekly. I think it depends on your personality what works best.