Food Talk And Fabulous Finds - Oatmeal is filling? Not for me!




View Full Version : Oatmeal is filling? Not for me!


souvenirdarling
12-11-2010, 03:27 PM
Everywhere I read that oatmeal is a great breakfast and very filling.

Now, I need a filling breakfast. My student mornings begin early and I need something that will hold me for four hours otherwise I end up snacking all day long!

I made MeloMeals' delicious "pumpkin spice" oatmeal which is made with pureed carrot and white beans. i also added sesame seeds and raisons, and ate a solid portion with a microwaved apple instead of adding sugar. Delicious!

I found that I would be satisfied (not FULL) after maybe half, and then HUNGRY an hour or two later.

I use Robin Hood Large Flake Oats. Is this the "wrong kind" of oat that's not filling?

On the other hand, my breakfast of choice is a whole wheat english muffin with an egg, slices of turkey and a ff kraft cheese slice, some fruit on the side, keeps me going much longer.

I've considered it's the protein content. Anyone else have a similar experience?


katy trail
12-11-2010, 03:42 PM
what about adding a small amount of peanut butter or other but butter to the oatmeal? lots of people like this, and the protein keeps them going longer.

for me, it can't be just any oatmeal. that instant fluff won't help at all. but if i use the unprocessed kind, it works fine, but i don't have to have protein at each meal i need volume, fiber.

maybe try a egg white omelet with lots of veggies in a wrap? you'll want lots of options. no one wants eggs EVERY day.

Rosinante
12-11-2010, 03:56 PM
I find plain old boring old oats more filling than fancied ones. I have 1/4 cup dry weight of oats, microwaved in half a cup of water for 2 minutes, sprinkled with 1/2oz ground flaxseed/nuts mix and 4 oz plain yogurt. This holds me for up to 6 hours. :)


quince
12-11-2010, 04:17 PM
dear souvenirdarling, i can totally relate, i can't believe someone really feels full for hours after an oatmeal breakfast.
i do eat oatmeal, though. i add some protein powder in it and it makes a world of difference. carbohidrates can't make me feel full, i guess it's my insuline going crazy after i eat something like that and makes me hungry. weather it is protein powder or eating something like an egg, or adding some healthy fats from nuts or similar helps alot.

RoseRodent
12-11-2010, 05:00 PM
I think you have to find what works for you. You can take the suggestions from what works for other people, but I don't feel full on fruit and veg, I don't feel full on protein. I've carefully tracked all my nutrition on Fitday for months and found the correct balance for me and I need minimum 50% carb calories or I feel hungry all day long. If you don't find your body responding in the same way others seem to then try the next suggestion down the line instead of trying to make it work.

I find fats filling, so I have to try to go with the healthier fats, olive oil, nuts, etc. I eat a fair number of eggs because they are protein and fat and that fills me up well if balanced with a carb, so boiled eggs and a small slice of bread (210 cals) fills me 100 times more than 210 cals of cereals.

The most filling food for me is salad onions/spring onions. I always liked the taste but not the texture, but I've been working on eating them, and one head of spring onion keeps me full for hours due to the strong taste. Sometimes I just have to smell onions and I feel full.

QuilterInVA
12-11-2010, 05:08 PM
Make the oatmeal with milk instead of water. That will add protein without adding more fat. Or have a hard boiled egg with your oatmeal. I use steel cut oats, peaches, and 1 T almonds and then have my egg.

carter
12-11-2010, 05:21 PM
I have the same experience with oatmeal - it doesn't really do much for me, though I enjoy it while it's happening. People's suggestions for adding stuff to it are good ideas.

I tend to make steel-cut oats (the kind that take a good half hour to cook) on cold winter weekend mornings when I've slept in and it's not too long till lunchtime. I also sometimes bake up an apple in the microwave and cut that in - it helps bulk it up for me.

To bake an apple in the microwave - core an apple and put it in a microwave-safe bowl or dish. Add a few tablespoons of water, a little cinnamon/nutmeg/whatever you like, and a small sprinkle of sugar or your favorite sugar substitute (I just use the real thing because I use such a tiny amount). Cover with plastic wrap and cook in the microwave for 4 minutes or so.

AnnieDrews
12-11-2010, 07:57 PM
I wouldn't say I stay stuffed for hours, but it satisfies me for about 4 hours. I do, however, drink the bulk of my water (and some coffee) for the day during those 4 hours, so that may be part of it.

I use 1/2 cup dry Quaker Old Fashioned Oats (do NOT like the instant) made with one cup of water for each serving I make. I always make up 5 servings every Sunday evening for my breakfast during the week and store it in the fridge in plastic containers. I also use lots of cinnamon, butter flavor extract (for the taste/aroma without the added calories) and then I sprinkle on Splenda brown sugar after I heat it up. I also love to add frozen dark sweet cherries (UNsweetened) when I heat it up, too. So good. Also good with cooked apples, pears or chopped up canned peaches.

JenMusic
12-11-2010, 08:29 PM
I'm with you - oats alone will not fill me up. Instant are the worst offenders but even with rolled or steel-cut, I'm hungry not a couple of hours later.

I still love oats, though, and they're so good for you, so I've started mixing them (uncooked rolled oats) into my morning Greek yogurt. With some berries, this is an amazing breakfast that DOES keep me satisfied for 4 hours or so.

darway
12-12-2010, 05:47 PM
I'm partial to "Bob's Red Mill 5 Grain". You can get plenty of instant oats cheap at ALDI and it's OK... but Bob's is a little chewier and heartier, and I think a slightly slower digest. I find it at Harris Teeter and the Natural Food stores.

Krazy
12-12-2010, 07:46 PM
BetterOats Blueberry Muffin and Dark chocolate are the only instant oatmealís that have ever filled me up for more than 3 hours. I know chocolate oatmeal might sound nasty, but itís actually really tasty and filling.

Wildflower
12-12-2010, 09:57 PM
I know where you are coming from. I too am surprised that so many find oats to be so filling. I add soy or almond milk to mine and a tablespoon of peanutbutter and i am hungry a few hours later. The only thing i can think of is, they are so filling i can't eat enough of them to keep me full for 4, 5, 6 hours as others mention.

I usually only have a 1/4 cup with 1 T pb and milk alternative. Sometimes a banana. I've tried to eat more and even add extra fiber with oat bran or ground flax but i can't eat that much of them.

vdander24
12-12-2010, 10:46 PM
I DO like Oatmeal in the morning, but I definitely use the old-fashioned kind, not the instant. I usually add fruit and some almonds and they usually bulk things up.
As a result of this forum, I now add 1/2 cup of vegetables to my breakfast meal. So far it has helped.

Martina
12-13-2010, 12:47 AM
I make a dry breakfast cereal from the oatmeal. I take oatmeal, almonds,and dried fruit and mix it together and have a serving of that like I would a regular cereal. The nuts have protein and you get the fiber from the oats and such. As long as you eat a small 1/2 cup amount (or slightly larger even) usually you are good to go.

KenzideRhae
12-13-2010, 12:56 AM
I never just eat plain oatmeal, I always have mix ins. Usually have 1/2-3/4 cup oats and then mix in some sort of nut butter, Greek yoghurt, a banana, berries, or some sort of dried fruit. Depending on how many calories the oats + mixs in ends up being, I sometimes have some egg whites or veggie sausage as well. Having the oatmeal plus the other additions tends to keep me pretty satisfied for 4 hours or so.

ptsmith59
12-26-2010, 04:21 PM
I love steel-cut oatmeal. It's good with homemade applesauce on it. (I cook a whole batch of apples in the crock pot, mash them up and then refrigerate it). The applesauce makes a delicious topping to my daily oatmeal along with some chopped almonds. Yum.

runsfromcameras
12-30-2010, 06:10 AM
If I eat breakfast I find myself hungrier through the day than if I don't have breakfast even when I am drinking enough water. I think I need to just retrain my body how to eat, what to eat and when to eat it.

Bobbolink
12-30-2010, 10:49 AM
Oatmeal is so good for you and delicious but it doesn't keep me full either. It takes fiber to keep me feeling full in the mornings and a serving of oatmeal only has 4 grams. I eat a serving of Fiber One in the mornings with fruit and yogurt. The cereal alone has 14 grams of fiber and only 60 calories, quite a difference than the oatmeal. Try switching to a high fiber cereal and see if that helps with the morning hunger pains.

ilovescience
01-04-2011, 01:54 AM
Two words: Oat bran! Oat bran takes less time to make in the microwave, and is far superior nutritionally! More protein, more fiber, but similar calorie/fat content.

I eat oat bran every morning with PB (for a bit more fat/protein) and love it!

darway
01-04-2011, 07:56 AM
Following up on Bobbolink's comment - regular instant store brand oats is 4 grams fiber. But "Bob's Red Mill" is 5. That may be why I sensed it is heartier.

joyfulloser
01-04-2011, 09:49 AM
I think if your hungry, you should eat.:)

I eat every 2-3 hours all day;) It's not how often you eat that counts...it's the amount of calories you consume in a day that counts. Find low calorie filling snacks coupled with high protein snacks to hold you over until the next meal. That's frankly what I suggest. Happy eating!!!:p