100 lb. Club - Muscle, weight, vanity sizing




View Full Version : Muscle, weight, vanity sizing


Eliana
08-08-2010, 12:04 PM
I just looked up the average size of a US woman because when I went shopping a few days ago I had a hard time finding size 10's. So I was assuming size 10 would be average and was really just curious. I found a couple odd numbers.

1. 5'4" 162 pounds and size 14

2. 5'4" 140 pounds size 14

3. I am 5'4" 170 pounds and a size 10 :dizzy:

Now, the size part is arbitrary and meaningless because, whose size 14 is it? Targets? Gaps? Liz Claiborne? I imagine my size 10 is about the "size 14" these articles suggest.

But 140 pounds and a size 14? And how is there such a big difference in the weights? Who's doing these studies? And both studies were done in 2010. And one study said we've gained 11 pounds since the last time this study was done.

Does anyone have any accurate info or reputable sites to check out? That's if you care to discuss this. ;) I just find it interesting.


ChunkyDunk78
08-08-2010, 12:52 PM
I've always heard it as 5'4" and 150 lbs.

But, I've never heard sizes, most likely because that depends on body shape, muscle, etc as well. But weighing 140 lbs and wearing a size 14... Hmm... Perhaps? Seems like that would be pretty pear shaped... Last time I weighed around 180 lbs, I work a 16-18 I believe... And I'm 5'8"... Hmm.

AR4life
08-08-2010, 01:08 PM
I don't think the size 14 and 140lbs can be right. I'm 132lbs at the moment and almost 5'4" I vary from size 2-4-6. This sizing depends on the store of course. At the higher end stores eg Banana republic, I'm a 2.

Are American and Canadian sizes that much different?


Eliana
08-08-2010, 01:14 PM
US sizes just keep getting bigger and I think UK sizes have stayed the same, though I could be wrong. I don't know where Canada falls, but I remember in high school UK sizes were always one higher than American sizes and now they're two higher. But really, it completely depends on the store. I don't think an American woman can any longer claim to be any particular size.

nitenurse
08-08-2010, 02:47 PM
im 5'6 and 145 lbs and i wear a size 12. I could squeeze in a 10 but i hate a muffin top

ducktape54
08-08-2010, 02:56 PM
I am 5'3 and about 175 and wear a size 16 or 14....just getting brave enough to try on some size 14s. But size are weird one store i got a 14 another one I had to get a 18 to make sure it was loose enough in the hip area

saef
08-08-2010, 04:12 PM
I'm 5'3" and about 142, & I believe I am "between sizes" right now, as the saying goes. I wear either a size 10 or an eight. My waist is small & swims in size 10, & so you'd think I'd be an eight, but my thighs seem to be causing issues lately in size eight. (I think it's my quads.)

The real conundrum is on top -- sometimes I'm a Medium Petite & other times I'm a Small Petite. Really, it seems to go 50/50.

But numbers mean nothing in the wacky world of women's clothing sizes.

Case in point: I got myself a very, very nice sweater the other day -- I mean, very nice, with a European salesgirl wrapping it in tissue paper & putting on a gold-sealed sticker & placing it inside a rope-handled shopping bag --& in that store, I had to buy an XL. Yeah, an XL. Had you asked me about this beforehand, I would have predicted that I'd be upset at being an XL, after all my hard work. But it was like an out-of-body experience & I could not find it in me to take it personally. I haven't worn a real XL in clothing since 2007, so I feel amused more than anything else

Eliana
08-08-2010, 04:22 PM
.

Case in point: I got myself a very, very nice sweater the other day -- I mean, very nice, with a European salesgirl wrapping it in tissue paper & putting on a gold-sealed sticker & placing it inside a rope-handled shopping bag --& in that store, I had to buy an XL. Yeah, an XL. Had you asked me about this beforehand, I would have predicted that I'd be upset at being an XL, after all my hard work. But it was like an out-of-body experience & I could not find it in me to take it personally. I haven't worn a real XL in clothing since 2007, so I feel amused more than anything else

Awesome!! I used to buy really nice clothes...I want to buy really nice clothes again! That size XL means nothing, as we both know. It's just its size at that store.

ubergirl
08-08-2010, 05:44 PM
I just looked up the average size of a US woman because when I went shopping a few days ago I had a hard time finding size 10's. So I was assuming size 10 would be average and was really just curious. I found a couple odd numbers.

1. 5'4" 162 pounds and size 14

2. 5'4" 140 pounds size 14

3. I am 5'4" 170 pounds and a size 10 :dizzy:

Now, the size part is arbitrary and meaningless because, whose size 14 is it? Targets? Gaps? Liz Claiborne? I imagine my size 10 is about the "size 14" these articles suggest.


But 140 pounds and a size 14? And how is there such a big difference in the weights? Who's doing these studies? And both studies were done in 2010. And one study said we've gained 11 pounds since the last time this study was done.

Does anyone have any accurate info or reputable sites to check out? That's if you care to discuss this. ;) I just find it interesting.

Regarding "average"... that doesn't seem very meaningful. You'd have to compare people of the same height, weight, gender, and fitness status to make any kind of meaningful comparison.

As I mentioned on another thread, I just tried on a 20 year old Talbot's jeans skirt in size 14 and got a pretty big shock. It wouldn't even THINK about fitting...even though I'm fitting nicely into 12s now in a lot of brands. The skirt belonged to my mom, who is coincidentally, 5'4" and 140. It does fit her, although it's not too big for her.

Quillie
08-08-2010, 06:05 PM
American sizes are way off, I remember when I went to visit my friend, I was a size Medium in the US, while here in Europe I already had to shop at special larger sizes stores. No need to say I LOVED shopping in the US! (I was about 180 lbs for 5'8" at the time, if memory serves me well)

Vanity sizing happens here too though, my old '10's are definitely smaller then the new ones, especially in the boobie area.

JennieLovesKisses
08-08-2010, 06:31 PM
I'm 5'3" and 174lbs, right now I'm wearing very loose size 14s, can't quite fit into 12 yet.

Latchkey Princess
08-08-2010, 07:05 PM
I don't know, but the change in clothing sizes has driven me nuts! I've bought nothing but larger clothes (ie, bigger than what I already owned) for YEARS now. So buying them on the way back down the scale is getting confusing. For instance, when I was a junior in high school (only 10-11 years ago) at one point I was a size 18 at 5'4" and about 190lbs. Right now I'm a comfy size 18 at 220lbs, and I can get a pair of 16's on but can't zip them up yet. It's crazy!

FitGirlyGirl
08-08-2010, 08:59 PM
I'm not really sure what the difference is between new sizes and old ones because I haven't saved any clothes that would tell me, but I know darn well there is a difference. The amount of muscle a person has definitely also causes differences. I have more muscle than a lot of women and I am currently headed into an 8 (I can fit into a stretch 8 just fine now, but while I can zip a non-stretch, they are way too tight to actually wear) and I am 5'2" and 165.

SilverLife
08-08-2010, 09:04 PM
I haven't been clothes shopping at a department store for a few years. I've been buying things at thrift stores.

I am 5' 7" and at 129-132 pounds I wear my size 10 clothes.
Up to 150, I wear my size 12 clothes.

I have size 10 and 12 clothes from the late 1970s through ca. 2000. It sounds as though a real size 10 has been re-named to an 8 or a 6.

In the 1940s, the size I wear was named a 14 or sometimes a 16. I have some of my mother's old things.

cheryl126
08-08-2010, 09:51 PM
I was a size 14 when I was around 180lbs at 5'5" However, my grandma, who never threw anything out, had a lot of "size 14" clothes from the 40's and 50's that were really more like a size 8 in today's sizes.

evilwomaniamshe
08-08-2010, 11:19 PM
I had to buy an XL. Yeah, an XL. Had you asked me about this beforehand, I would have predicted that I'd be upset at being an XL, after all my hard work. But it was like an out-of-body experience & I could not find it in me to take it personally. I haven't worn a real XL in clothing since 2007, so I feel amused more than anything else

Saef, my hubby calls XL (extra little) when I sometime also buy that size just because some things runs so small, isn't that a hoot extra little? Sizes run so differently, but when I see the XL, I always smile and think "extra little" these days! :D

anmitche
08-09-2010, 10:38 AM
I am 5'3" and weigh 185 pounds. I wear a size 14 now, but I bought some size 12's this weekend that I can wear if I don't mind muffin top. I do, so I'll wait about five pounds before wearing them. :)

Eliana
08-09-2010, 10:49 AM
Yes, I won't do the muffin top either. I'll do a tiny muffin top when I'm sitting, but if I'm muffining even a little when I'm standing then those pants do not fit. ;)

saef
08-09-2010, 06:14 PM
Thank you, Eliana, for my 3FC verb of the day: "muffining"

This is like when I saw someone post "ellipticalling."

Both completely understandable new verbs. Both highly useful for 3FC conversations.

Eliana
08-09-2010, 07:21 PM
"Weighting" has been a new one to me. I don't think it's a real word...maybe it is. But it's certainly appropriate at 3FC! Gosh, that could be a whole different thread.

calluna
08-09-2010, 08:44 PM
:rofl: too bad we don't have a "muffining" animated emoticon. :D

tryn2bfit
08-10-2010, 01:30 AM
hey ladies!
i wear a size 12 right now and i am 209lbs and 5'5. i despise the muffin top too which is why i am waiting for a bit to try 10's