General chatter - Can fat turn into muscle or muscle turn into fat?




kiahna23
08-22-2009, 03:09 PM
I already know the answer to this...but I just want to see how many people dont...I was arguing with my hubbies family...when people play sports they think they know everything about fitness, diet and nutrition...I just want to know what you know and what you dont understand...And see if Im the only one here...

Do you think fat can turn into muscle...or muscle can turn into fat?


caryesings
08-22-2009, 03:13 PM
No!!

matafleur
08-22-2009, 03:16 PM
Can cats turn into dogs and dogs turn into cats? No - but you can replace a cat with a dog (or vise versa).


kaplods
08-22-2009, 03:26 PM
The technical answer is "no," however I think the way people use the information, it doesn't matter. So, if someone says the exercise can turn fat into muscle they may or may not realize that what they're really saying is that exercise can help a person replace fat with with muscle.

Does it matter that the new muscle isn't made of the same molecules as the fat was, or does it only matter that the person has muscle where they once had fat?

Now, if the people are saying that it is EASY to replace fat with muscle - that's an entirely different argument.

kiahna23
08-22-2009, 03:31 PM
The technical answer is "no," however I think the way people use the information, it doesn't matter. So, if someone says the exercise can turn fat into muscle they may or may not realize that what they're really saying is that exercise can help a person replace fat with with muscle.

Does it matter that the new muscle isn't made of the same molecules as the fat was, or does it only matter that the person has muscle where they once had fat?

Now, if the people are saying that it is EASY to replace fat with muscle - that's an entirely different argument.

I was asking for the factual answer....thats all...when people say it they think of literally fat turning into muscle....so basically a 340lb person will turn all the fat into muscle...wow! how buff would he be? It isnt all replaced with muscle....especially with women...when we lose fat our muscle cant build that big to fill the areas where we lost the fat....If it did we wou ld be pretty buff...lol...

kiahna23
08-22-2009, 03:33 PM
Can cats turn into dogs and dogs turn into cats? No - but you can replace a cat with a dog (or vise versa).

Good answer....that was funny too! LOL

kiramira
08-22-2009, 03:49 PM
Uh, NO. With exercise, fat is used as fuel and muscle builds through the process of stressing it creating microtears and healing creating bigger muscles. The size of the muscle is a reflection of the amount of stress you put on it. Once you stop using it, the muscle is not longer needed so it "wastes away" (just think of the calf muscles of a person who has been in a wheelchair for a long time -- nonuse of muscle means muscle atrophy). If you eat too many calories, the excess is stored as body fat.

If you bodybuild and get great muscles, then stop bodybuilding, your muscles will shrink in size. If you continue to eat the same amount that you were when bodybuilding, you'll get a layer of fat over top. If you moderate your eating, you will lose muscle still and won't get the fat over top. This happened to a friend of ours who went directly from body building to long distance running. He changed from a mini-Arnold to a super-lean-muscled runner. But his muscle didn't turn into fat.

And sometimes a question is just a question, not an exploration of the metaphysical implications suggested by grammatical sentence construction...sometimes a cigar is just a cigar...:rofl:

Kira

harrismm
08-22-2009, 03:54 PM
I already know the answer to this...but I just want to see how many people dont...I was arguing with my hubbies family...when people play sports they think they know everything about fitness, diet and nutrition...I just want to know what you know and what you dont understand...And see if Im the only one here...

Do you think fat can turn into muscle...or muscle can turn into fat?

LOL!!Sounds like my husband...always trying to outsmart me!When will he ever learn???????????

JayEll
08-22-2009, 04:39 PM
Fat is a different type of body tissue (adipose connective tissue) than muscle (muscle tissue). These cannot change from one into the other. The answer is no.

Active muscle is able to burn fatty acids, so in that sense exercise can help reduce the amount of fat in the body. But it isn't that one changes into the other.

Jay

kiahna23
08-22-2009, 04:56 PM
LOL!!Sounds like my husband...always trying to outsmart me!When will he ever learn???????????

Men...lol...no but it wasnt my husband it was his family...When one says something they all gang up on you...they take sticking together to a whole new..obsessed level...LMAO.....

kiahna23
08-22-2009, 04:59 PM
Fat is a different type of body tissue (adipose connective tissue) than muscle (muscle tissue). These cannot change from one into the other. The answer is no.

Active muscle is able to burn fatty acids, so in that sense exercise can help reduce the amount of fat in the body. But it isn't that one changes into the other.

Jay

See! Why do we all know but some people seem to swear they know and they dont! lI think its their ego's....they graduated college already and I graduate next year...So they think their "smarter" than I am...Its my major! Health science.....Im going for nursing but I want to be able to give people correct information when they ask so I take courses that I dont really need...

harrismm
08-22-2009, 05:49 PM
I was just thinking how funny we would look if fat DID turn into muscle.Can you imagine?My babies had the fattest cheeks and feet....baby fat goes away.........Oh great....now they have cheek and toe muscles...LMAO.

rockinrobin
08-23-2009, 07:34 AM
Not everybody is versed in every topic and to think that they are is not realistic. I don't necessarily get "annoyed" when someone is ignorant on a subject. Of course if they state their opinion over and over and over again as fact and it's false, that could get a little bothersome. But if someone is 100% wrong, I try to gently point it out, without making them feel - dopey. No one knows everything. I learn new things all the time and hope to never, ever stop.

This just reminded me of the often thrown around statement that fat weighs more then muscle. When of course it's that one pound of muscle weighs the same as one pound of fat, but that the muscle takes up less space.

BillBlueEyes
08-23-2009, 09:44 AM
SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT
In our cover story on exercise, we suggested that fat could be converted to muscle. It cannot be. [Aug 17.] Muscle, which is built up, and fat, which is burned, are different types of tissue.

Time Magazine, August 23, 2009, Page 6.--

kiahna23
08-23-2009, 06:36 PM
I was just thinking how funny we would look if fat DID turn into muscle.Can you imagine?My babies had the fattest cheeks and feet....baby fat goes away.........Oh great....now they have cheek and toe muscles...LMAO.

:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl:

MAN! That would look pretty wack! That was a good one....

kiahna23
08-23-2009, 06:41 PM
Not everybody is versed in every topic and to think that they are is not realistic. I don't necessarily get "annoyed" when someone is ignorant on a subject. Of course if they state their opinion over and over and over again as fact and it's false, that could get a little bothersome. But if someone is 100% wrong, I try to gently point it out, without making them feel - dopey. No one knows everything. I learn new things all the time and hope to never, ever stop.

This just reminded me of the often thrown around statement that fat weighs more then muscle. When of course it's that one pound of muscle weighs the same as one pound of fat, but that the muscle takes up less space.

Its not that I get annoyed but they do this to me all the time..They went to college so their mother could brag..then they ALL moved back home to stay mostly because they went for a sucky major...THey gang up on me ALOT...And my husband just shuts up because he doesnt want to offend them...I may have gotten my GED and went to college but I have a higher GPA then all of them combined and I genuinely educate myself...I listen to htem if I know I dont know the answer...but If I know i do know for sure...it gets pretty pesty...I even show proof and they say " I still dont believe it".....

kiahna23
08-23-2009, 06:44 PM
--

they wouldnt even believe me if i told them...or proved it...I just cant stand them! They also believe that if you drink even on rare occations you get diabetes! Im like NO! If you drink too often it has been said you can get diabetes...but NO if you drink the occasional glass of wine you will be for the most part okay...