I like to try to treat each day individually. After a high day, I might cut back a little bit on subsequent days, but I would probably do something like omit my Skinny Cow ice cream treat or try to be more conscious about sodium. I try to keep my weekly average around 1700; sometimes I'm under and sometimes I'm a little over but I don't let one higher-calorie day get me too rattled. If I have 2 of them in a week, then it's time to re-evaluate my plan and my committment level.
I've found that restricting the day after might play a part in sending me over the edge again the next day. I might cut out a few empty calories (like a pp mentioned). Also, sometimes the day after, I'm not as hungry, so I might eat less calories then my daily limit.
I thought this thread was going to be about bad dads and I could share about how my dad used to say I was fat.
But, since it's about bad days, I'll share that I don't restrict the next day, I just go back to eating normally. Maybe I'll have more veggies depending on what I overate the day before, but that is just because if I had fewer veggies the day before I'm probably going to be craving them the next day anyway.
My caloric intake is different everyday depending on how active I am or am not. If I have a 'bad day,' I just keep going. Restricting is pretty negative, especially when you are active, all that is doing is punishing you/your body.
I would not punish myself, I would not let myself get hungry and "try to make up for it". What's done is.
What I would do - is try and decipher why I went so high on my calories. Did I not have healthy foods on hand to eat? Did I not plan well? Was I not happy with my food selections? Did I let let temptation get to me by forgetting my long term wants and desires instead of my short term ones? Did I let myself get too hungry and then just "over did it"?
Remember, one day of "off" eating in the scope of things is no biggie. But 2 is another story. So yes, get back to it today. No harm done.
Location: Lyin' in a puddle of sweat on the floor.
Posts: 2,296
S/C/G: 235/201/175
Height: 5'7"
Planned calorie cycling is one thing. Just having a crappy day where carb cravings or a party at work gets to you is just a speed bump. Just go right back to your plan. You're looking for a new "normal", long term, so keep your mind on the long term goal of developing healthier eating and exercise habits, not this week's weigh in. The effects of a high cal day might be that the scale goes up a little for a day or two, but if you're otherwise sticking to your plan, that's all it does, it's not permanent, and it'll be just a note in your journal a couple of days from now. Like Robin said, learn from it, and move on.
I had to answer that it is a good idea to restrict calories after a bad food day, but that was before I read what you were suggesting.
You cannot make up for overeating by then undereating by the same amount. That is a no-win cycle that leads to further bingeing. One also shouldn't overexercise in an attempt to make up for it.
It might be OK to go 100-150 calories below your target level for two or three days following a really big day--that's what I mean by restricting calories. That isn't likely to get cyclic. Just keep in mind that you may not see much loss that week.
And as rockinrobin suggested, try to see what caused you to go off the plan.
I thought this thread was going to be about bad dads and I could share about how my dad used to say I was fat.
But, since it's about bad days, I'll share that I don't restrict the next day, I just go back to eating normally. Maybe I'll have more veggies depending on what I overate the day before, but that is just because if I had fewer veggies the day before I'm probably going to be craving them the next day anyway.
Yeah! I was starting to wonder if I was the only one who was expecting a rant about a tragic childhood after reading the thread's title.
I would just try to eat a about 1500-1600 the next day. And I also like to eat as much fiber (esp insoluble fiber) the next day as I can. Oatmeal for breakfast and make sure I get all my fruits & veggies in the next day too! It might actually do your body good to have a higher day every once in awhile because then your body won't "think there is a food shortage" and won't think it needs to hold on to all your fat! Darn caveman genes!
how do you recover from a bad day?
and I could share about how my dad used to say I was fat. 
