100 lb. Club - Opinions? Watching the scale...




View Full Version : Opinions? Watching the scale...


DollyR
03-24-2008, 05:23 PM
I have been through phases of watching the scale everyday and then not looking at the scale at all for several weeks. I know people out there say it is better to stay away from weighing everyday but I think I maintain or lose better if I do. I gained a considerable amount of weight this winter because I threw caution to the wind.

What do you think?


pipernoswiper
03-24-2008, 05:28 PM
i weigh myself 3-4 times a week and i always weigh myself at the same time (in the morning) it just helps me stay honest with myself.

Anjera
03-24-2008, 05:40 PM
I have been scale obsessed before. I try not to watch the scale nowadays because it was too much for me. My ultimate goal is now a size goal rather than a weight goal because I tend to weigh more than my size indicates (I lift weights as part of my fitness routine and of course muscle weighs more...)
Don't let it get you down and try to ween yourself off the scale watching is all I can suggest.


amouse
03-24-2008, 05:41 PM
i weight myself everymoring and record the weight on calori king it is very interesting to see how the little graph changes from one day to the next.. during a week my weight can go up 3 times then . i have a big drop.. lol its funny i know but its just the way it always goes.. i have a patteren happening up up up big drop.. up drop. up up up big drop.. lol and im losing atm 1-2 pounds a week .. If you are aware of your body i dont believe daily weighing is a problem.. if your obsessive about the fluctuations.. weigh your self once a week .. but i see a problem in the once a week.. what if that day you are more bloated ?? you have no way on knowing if that is your actual weight.. lmao.. so each to there own..

midwife
03-24-2008, 05:45 PM
I weigh every day and it helps me stay on plan. There are fluctuations, but it is the trend that is helpful. I spent too many years ignoring the scale. If daily weighing helps you stay on your path, then do it!

bigtxmomma
03-24-2008, 05:50 PM
I guess it depends what your goal is. I think if you are trying earnestly to lose pounds, it's good to check in to see how you are progressing. I think I'd be upset if I worked my butt off but maybe doing something wrong, but I didn't know that because I wasn't keeping track.

There was a good quote on someone's ticker, that weighing isn't necessarily the best way to track progress, but it's better than any other way!

I never weighed myself regularly until I started on this weight loss attempt in January, and keeping up with weighing myself keeps me motivated and focused. It's also really interesting to see how my body fluctuates. And if one week I lose a pound or two more, I go back and think about what I did differently. Also, I'm doing South Beach, and as I'm introducing carbs back into what I'm eating, it's interesting to see if I can maintain weight loss wit what foods I'm introducing. Otherwise I probably would be distracted and not think about it and then maybe I'd gain back all the weight I lost.

I think it's an individual thing, but I'd say weigh in. Not compulsively, but like once a week. (I do an official weigh in Monday mornings, but I check my weight a couple times a week, and the fluctuation of the scale doesn't kill my motivation.)

sarahdafiregal
03-24-2008, 06:17 PM
I've been through both phases as well. This first week was great because I saw a loss every day. However, once I weigh myself and it shows a gain I know I'll be beating myself up. But it's an obsession....I think that seeing the numbers change, going down of course, makes me feel like I've accomplished something...even if I don't feel it physically. I'm sure the first gain I have, I'll be throwing the darn thing out the window!!!!!;) Who'd of thought we'd be addicted to a scale when in the past we hated it?!?!

Lyn2007
03-24-2008, 06:30 PM
For 15 years I have been trying everything under the sun with regards to weight loss. In the past, I tried very hard to heed everyone's advice to only weigh once a week. It drove me nuts. I could not STAND to wait a week. I would think about weighing ALL THE TIME. Then after a few dasy I would sneak and weigh and then if I had not lost, I would flip out and binge. BAD trend there.

Finally, I realized I was giving too much power to the scale. For me, the answer has been to weigh every day, ONCE a day in the morning when I get up. I record the weight on a chart. Doing this takes all the power out of the numbers for me. I see the trends that go weekly and monthly. I take note if I gain or lose but the overall trend needs to be downward.

Now I am no longer scale obsessed. I know I get my daily scale fix and that's all I need. It has really worked out for me and I think helped keep me from gaining over the winter.

JimmieLynn
03-24-2008, 06:41 PM
I used to weigh my self every morning, right after i got up and went potty. At first, I really thought it helped me, but then I became obsessed with whatever number I saw daily, and it would set up my whole day, good or bad.

Now, I only weigh myself 1 or 2 times a week. I still feel like I am maintaining and holding myself accountable. I definitely think its a matter of what works for you.

MamaToTomAndAlex
03-24-2008, 06:49 PM
Honestly.... I think it depends on the person.

If you are the kind of person who is emotionally affected every time the scale shows a gain.... then I think it's a really bad idea to be a scale hopper. :)

I am on the scale several times a day... lol... but I've been doing this for years. I know if I have a salty meal the night before, the next day I'm going to be showing a gain and I'm happy with that. I know if I've not been drinking my water I'll show a gain.... or if it's that time of the month. I've been doing it for soooooo long now I know the highs and lows I get every week and every month and a gain doesn't effect me... if anything it helps. If I see I'm up on the scale I'll figure out why and then I'll up my water intake or whatever to compensate for it.

Am I making any sense?? lol :)

GirlyGirlSebas
03-24-2008, 06:58 PM
I weigh every morning....and, only that one time every day. This keeps me accountable with myself and let's me know if I'm on track with my plan. Of course, seeing the scale go up a few pounds overnight for no apparent reason was very discouraging in the beginning. Now, I'm used to the fluctuations and they don't have as big an impact on my attitude and they don't cause me to go off-plan.

fiberlover
03-24-2008, 07:59 PM
I personally don't see any problem weighing once a day

*if*

- you understand there will be daily fluctuations
- you don't let daily fluctuations get you off track
- you don't play games with the scale (like hopping on and off, trimming your nails, cleaning out belly button lint, etc)


If you find yourself weighing more than once a day, ban the scale.

LaurieDawn
03-24-2008, 08:13 PM
If I'm giving the time and energy to my weight loss plan that I need to, I weigh every day. If circumstances prevent me from getting the sleep that I need (which is a key ingredient of my weight loss) I won't weigh every day. I still try to stay true to my eating and exercise plans, but I know I won't show a loss if I don't sleep much, though I can easily show a gain, so I stay off until I can get sleep again. As everyone has said, it's whatworks for you. And it sounds like weighing every day works for you. So embrace the fact that you've found a tool that helps you succeed and don't worry about the rest.

famograham
03-24-2008, 08:29 PM
I weigh myself every morning. I don't let it decide how my day goes, and I do understand daily fluctuations. But sometimes it does get a tad frustrating to see the same number...I get a bit anxious after six days or so! ;) I'm quite annoyed at maintaining this week! But it's not a huge deal.

:hug:
Linda

bluex
03-24-2008, 08:39 PM
I weighed every day but didn't worry about fluctuations. By measuring every day, I learned to feel when I was retaining water, when I was dropping my water weight. I learned that as long as it wasn't many pounds that I had gained, it was probably water. I didn't worry about the day to day but the overall picture.

I also read once that one of the keys to maintenance was weighing daily. If you do it every day you can catch yourself sliding into bad habits before you gain too much weight.

LisaF
03-24-2008, 10:29 PM
I weigh every day, but only record once a week. Interestingly, for me, weighing every day takes some of the power away from the scale. Because I weigh every day I have concrete evidence of how varied flucuations can be, so I don't start freaking out if things are up. If things are up a couple of days in a row, though, that's a signal to me to pay more attention to what I'm doing.

I have also read that daily weighing is a key to sucessful maintenance. I tracked down an article (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/10/16/AR2006101600942.html) about the study. It's an interesting read.

Lisa


Lisa

Cassie501107
03-24-2008, 10:52 PM
I weight everyday...it keeps me on track. Only report it "officially" on Mondays though.:dizzy:

Trazey34
03-24-2008, 11:12 PM
I can't deal with the emotional rollercoaster of weighing everyday LOL, either feel GREAT cuz I'm down a bit or BUMMED cuz i'm up, can't face that feeling every day :)

I know I'm on the right path, so I don't need it to remind myself of what I'm doing, so I weigh in once a week, two times in a row to be sure it's accurate, and that's it I'm afraid.

I do like to try on some crazy small pants once a week too ;)

xGurlyGrlx
03-25-2008, 01:58 AM
I weigh once a week. It gives me something to look forward. My weekly treat is getting on the scale. It is fun. I weigh every Saturday regardless of TOM or feeling bloaty. I know that the number is what it is for that day and if I was bloaty or had water weight due to TOM or salt...it will show the next week at my weigh in. The pounds lost wont go away if I don't catch it on a specific day.

sarahdafiregal
03-25-2008, 09:34 AM
- you don't play games with the scale (like hopping on and off, trimming your nails, cleaning out belly button lint, etc)

Never thought of the belly button lint...although I do go to the bathroom before I weigh myself. ;)

mezmerize
03-25-2008, 09:59 AM
you don't play games with the scale (like hopping on and off, trimming your nails, cleaning out belly button lint, etc)

:rofl:
I think it's a personal thing also. If one can see a gain and not let it set them off their plan. Then there is nothing wrong with it.

LisaF
03-25-2008, 11:06 AM
I can't deal with the emotional rollercoaster of weighing everyday LOL, either feel GREAT cuz I'm down a bit or BUMMED cuz i'm up, can't face that feeling every day :)


Trazey, I think you've hit on the main difference, right there. For me, weighing daily has desensitized me to the scale, so getting on is no longer an emotional roller coaster. I totally understand what you mean, though. For about five years I didn't even own a scale, and the only time I got weighed was at the doctor's office. Boy was that traumatic!

Lisa

Hopefulpinkangel
03-25-2008, 04:02 PM
I weigh myself once a week. I have become scale obsessed in the past and drove myself crazy. I decided to only weigh myself once a week to avoid the "scale obsession" :)

DollyR
03-25-2008, 04:54 PM
I feel better about weighing everyday. I especially liked the article from the Washington Post it made me feel like it was ok to weigh in every morning. This morning I saw another loss and this gave me inspiration for the rest of the day!

findingfawn
03-25-2008, 05:01 PM
I weigh myself every morning after exercising. If I don't I forget my goals for the day.

yoyonomoreinvegas
03-25-2008, 05:34 PM
I personally don't see any problem weighing once a day

*if*

- you don't play games with the scale (like hopping on and off, trimming your nails, cleaning out belly button lint, etc)


Dang! You're on to me :rofl:

I actually do sometimes like to grab a morning and an afternoon/early evening weight just to get an idea of what kind of flux phase I'm in. And, even though it sure seems as though it can, I know my body isn't going to be able to manufacture a pound of fat in a 12 hour period so if I'm up a pound (or even two) in the evening I know I didn't get enough water and need to up it for the next day. But, it's kind of like everything else - it has to work for you. If the up fluctuations are going to throw you for a loop and make you want to give up then daily is not the way to go.

Beverlyjoy
03-25-2008, 06:38 PM
I try to weigh only once a week....once in a while I'll hop on midweek. But, actually - it can mess up my mind to weigh alot.

I can become scale obsessed. It can become disordered eating if I weigh too often - eating asparagus before a weigh day for it diuretic qualities or having lots of high fiber food so, well, you know "that" moves along too before I weigh.) I can't go that route anymore.

I have honestly tried to have a sane relationship with food and not be scale/weight obsessed. Mind you...I like it when the scale goes down - but, I don't freak out if it doesn't go down every week when I weigh.

My relationship with the scale has really evolved into a much healthier place for me.

joylove26
03-26-2008, 12:35 AM
I weigh every day and it helps me stay on plan. There are fluctuations, but it is the trend that is helpful. I spent too many years ignoring the scale. If daily weighing helps you stay on your path, then do it!

This is what I do too. It works for me.