South Beach Diet - Basmati vs Jasmine Rice




View Full Version : Basmati vs Jasmine Rice


LoveMySgt
12-09-2007, 09:18 PM
I know Basmati is a Ph 2 food but can someone tell me if I can sub Jasmine for it? They have the same nutritional information so I thought maybe it was just left of the list.

This is the kind I usually buy and in case I am not allowed to link it, it's Mahatma Jasmine Rice
http://www.mahatmarice.com/mahatmarice/product.cfm?productid=10695

Thanks


Schmoodle
12-09-2007, 09:23 PM
I think any rice is okay as long as it's brown rice or with the outer hull intact. The link you gave was for white rice, and you would want to avoid that on any phase, just like white bread vs. whole grain bread.

LoveMySgt
12-09-2007, 09:25 PM
Basmati is also a white rice and on the allowed food list. Oh the confusion! :)

Basmati -
http://www.mahatmarice.com/mahatmarice/product.cfm?productid=10667


Pearlrose
12-09-2007, 09:32 PM
I believe white rice has to be converted and not instant and should be okay. I think most of the mahat rices are converted? I know Uncle Ben's sells converted rice

LoveMySgt
12-09-2007, 09:41 PM
I know they have rice mixes but I don't think Mahatma sells instant rice.
I love my rice maker :)

kaplods
12-09-2007, 11:53 PM
Jasmine and Basmati (and the hybrids jasmati and texmati) are varieties of long grain fragrant rice. I would consider them interchangeable for most purposes. They all come in polished and brown or whole grain (rice without the bran removed is called brown rice, although the color isn't always brown). I have some black jasmine rice (since the bran hasn't been removed it's a brown rice, even though the color is dark purplish black). I haven't tried it yet.

Converted rice is precooked, I believe, but isn't processed to the degree that instant rice has been. I would think unprocessed brown rice, should be first choice, though this takes the longest to cook. It is also the most flavorful and has a nice nutty chewiness from the bran (and is more filling too because of all that fiber in the bran)

LoveMySgt
12-10-2007, 12:17 AM
Thanks. I really hate regular brown rice, even though I have tried really hard to like it. I will look to see what they have next time I go to the store because they usually have a good selection. I am making my grocery list now so wanted to be sure I could use it.

femmecreole
12-10-2007, 07:11 AM
Love, I also used to hate brown rice..because it never came out right for me. It was either like little rocks or mush. Being from Louisiana, I'm VERY picky about my rice...it's an artform here.
One day I was watching Alton Brown and he showed how to cook perfect brown rice, so I tried it...and it comes out just perfect every time. He used butter, so I subbed olive oil for the butter and it works just fine. He recommend using an 8"x8" glass dish:

1 1/2 cups long grain brown rice
2 1/2 cups water
1 tablespoon olive oil
1 teaspoon salt


Preheat oven to 375ºF.
Boil the water and add the olive oil and salt. Stir to dissolve.
Place the rice in an 8" casserole dish. Pour the boiling water mixture over the rice and stir.
Cover with foil and bake on the middle rack for 1 hour.
Fluff with fork and serve.

CyndiM
12-10-2007, 07:14 AM
Basmati rice is available brown. It has the nice basmati texture and taste. You might like it better than regular brown rice.

Ruthxxx
12-10-2007, 08:27 AM
Cat, I'd forgotten about baking rice! I used to do it all the time. Thanks for the reminder!

Schmoodle
12-10-2007, 10:14 AM
Oh, I'll try that Cat. I'm sure it's good if Alton made it!
I get the brown basmati from Trader Joe's.
I didn't know that any white rice was allowed.
What does it mean when rice is converted? I didn't know rice had religion. I think I would prefer my rice perverted anyway...

Barb0522
12-10-2007, 12:02 PM
The Good Fats/Good Carbs guide says that the following rice is good:
Brown
white, long-grain, converted (I buy Uncle Ben's)
wild

The following is limited:
arborio risotto
basmati
white, long-grain

The following is to be avoided:
brown, quick-cooking
glutinous
jasmine
white, instant

baking the rice sounds good but often I wouldn't have an hour to cook it so the 20 minutes that Uncle Ben's takes to make converted, works better for me.

D flip
12-10-2007, 12:08 PM
:) Schmoodle!!

LoveMySgt
12-10-2007, 03:19 PM
Barb - do you know why Jasmine is a nono?
(for Mahatma brand) It has the same nutritional info as Basmati and Long Grain White. Reading this thread, now know Basmati can also come in brown, does it mean brown only Basmati? I am just asking out of curiousity now.

Guess I will be looking for their Uncle Ben's next time. Thanks so much for the help!

LoveMySgt
12-10-2007, 04:01 PM
I did a little (ok a whole lot!) more reading and found out that Jasmine rice has a GL of 46 and Basmati is only 22. That explains it :)

eta for comparison - UB converted is about 14-16, don't remember which I read