ejenk,
There will always be someone who does not do good on a certain plan while others do very well. I started doing Wendie plan before I started weight watchers. I have always had good results with it. I went from 245 to 210 with it and then kind of went off plan. I am not back on weight watchers and as soon as I get back in the swing of it, I will be going back to the Wendie plan.
Wendie plan is a version of the flex where your 35 weekly points have already been distributed during the week for you. With out going and doing the math, I think there is all by 8 points used. I never found that I needed more points, but you can still use them extra ones if you needed to. Listen to your body to know. You can also earn Activity Points.
What could be bad about it, Of Course, You should follow the Weight watchers healthy eating guidelines, exercise and follow you points and you will lose weight.
The only way to know if it will work for you is to try it. If for some reason it does not work for you, go back to basic Flex. It is up to you.
Hope this helps.
There is a thread under the WW General catergory if you want to go check that out. These girls are doing well with it.
http://www.3fatchicks.com/forum/showthread.php?t=102020
Check it out.
Wendy