I hit a local nutrition store just down the street before hitting the mall for GNC. They had a nice selection!
For the time being I just grabbed one each of Cinnamon Roll, Coconut Cashew, and Apple Pie. They were $2.50 per bar (ouch), but eh, what the heck.
If they're worth it to me I'll definitely go back for more flavors!
Then I went to GNC and saw they had them as well, but they were something like $2.76 each. But they have a special deal right now if you buy three, you get one free. So if I like these enough I'll definitely go back to GNC as long as they have the special going.