I too dropped a bunch of money and ended up only liking:
1. Pancake syrup-I too will keep this even on maintenance
2. caramel syrup-super thick and great in coffee, chocolate drink, oatmeal muffins
3. marshmallow dip-use it only to thicken puddings and drinks and it makes them smooth and way better tasting
Sesame Ginger salad dressing
the others (dressings, jams, peanut spreads) are headed to the trash as soon as I can bring myself to do it.