Gastric Bypass is such a tough subject. Having worked and gone to school in the medical field, I can't imagine a doctor ethically recommending this without medical reasons and TOPS does not endorse this surgery.
Let me explain further. In the TOPS News, Feb 2000, page 4, Betty Dominoe, President of TOPS Club, Inc states, "This does not mean that we have dropped the SENSIBLY from our name. A basic food exchange plan and moderate exercise, along with good advice from a reputable medical advisor, should help members reach and maintain their weight goals. Our name still reflects our philosophy. We want you to TAKE OFF POUNDS SENSIBLY. TOPS is an addition to professional care. Each member has different hopes and dreams, different health conditions, and different weight-loss goals. You and your medical advisor determine how you will measure success. We Are Here for You!".
The guide book that TOPS publishes, The Choice Is Yours, pages 19 and 20, touches on some of the different ways that have been used to lose weight from gastric bypass to drugs. It mentions the dangers of these. TOPS does not endorse them. However, on page 38 of this book it states 'TOPS strongly recommends the Exchange System to it's members as the starting point of a weight loss program.'
The article referred to in Eleni's post above is in the TOPS News, Nov 2001 issue pages 12 & 23. Dr Kissebah, TOPS Medical advisor, advises the writer 'to go along with what your doctor advises' and acknowledges that 'it is very important to discuss these benefits and side effects in detail with your physician and operating surgeon before agreeing to undergo this surgery.'
I care a lot about what TOPS can offer all people and I just wanted to let newer members know that TOPS at one time did not allow members to be recognized for weight loss when it was lost under any 'artificial means'. This was such a broad subject that even things like Slim Fast, Dexatrim, Ayds {anybody remember those 'candies'???}, Metabolife, phen-fen, etc... fell into the same catagory as the medically advised surgery. TOPS realizes that there are those individuals with severe, life threatening obesity... and only their doctors can recommend what is best for them in getting healthier.
TOPS is a support group that was started 53 years ago to support, encourage, and cheer others on to healthier lives through weight loss and management. Even though I lost my weight 'naturally' and was state Queen Runner-up in 1995, I would not have minded if someone else had edged me out of that honor. As long as we would have gotten healthier....that is the main goal, in my opinion. KEEPING OFF the weight is the hardest thing......and unless one changes their ways, the weight will not stay off, with or without surgery.
I wish everyone success (with your doctors guidance) in your journey for better health.
TOPS Hugs,
Summer
|