3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community  

Go Back   3 Fat Chicks on a Diet Weight Loss Community > Support Forum > Support Groups > 100 lb. Club

Thread Tools
Old 03-04-2012, 11:56 AM   #1
hot. like a curry.
gloo's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: nor cal
Posts: 269

S/C/G: 308/248/150ish

Height: 5'4"

Default thoughts on BMI?

How do y'all feel about BMI as a measurement of health? It's become the standard used by doctors and insurance companies and actuaries use it to figure out mortality rates and such. But do you care about it or trust it as an accurate measure of fitness? Or do you use some other barometer of success?

I ask because my trainer and I were chatting about it recently, and I was horrified when he told me that he's considered overweight on the BMI charts. He's a young, slim and crazy fit boxer with killer abs, beautiful arms (seriously, my trainer has the body of Greek god) and ridiculously low body fat but he's not particularly tall (maybe 5'10"-ish). So the BMI powers that be deemed him overweight. I don't get it -- it all just seems really arbitrary to me.

Do you think it's a fair measurement? Asking out of sheer curiosity.

Happy Sunday!
blogness: little blue ticket (like a golden ticket. only little. and blue.)

the long and winding road:
gloo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 12:46 PM   #2
lovemydoggiesx2's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 356

S/C/G: 172/ticker/125

Height: 5´4.5


I personally think the BMI calculators are bologna. Every person has a different body, and I don´t understand how you can be judged strickly on your height and weight. It doesnt take into consider your fat vs. muscle. My ¨BMI¨is 28% and to be in the mid ¨normal¨range I need to be 125. I can tell you I haven´t been 125 since I was like 15 years old, and have no desire to be that low again.....

Just my thoughts. To play devil´s advocate, I´m sure it does have a true purpose or it wouldn´t still be around and used.
lovemydoggiesx2 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 12:48 PM   #3
thistoo's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Knoxville, TN
Posts: 2,317

Height: 5'0"


It's a decent guideline to get people in the ballpark of a healthy weight goal, but it's not the end-all. Lots of fit athletes with muscle mass are above their 'ideal' BMI because of their extra muscle weight.
thistoo is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 12:51 PM   #4
Leveling Up
sontaikle's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: New York
Posts: 3,655

S/C/G: 200+/115/115

Height: 5'3"


For the majority of the population, I think BMI is a good standard of measure. Most of us won't have the time/dedication/resources/drive to get to a place where one is so muscular that they're considered overweight or obese.

You don't necessarily have to go nuts trying to get into the healthy range, but it does provide some starting point for some folks.

For people like your trainer or athletes, it really isn't a good standard of measure. Any doctor should be able to see that they're healthy though and just a muscular person when they look at them vs what the scale says.

Go watch 300. Gerard Butler is considered "obese" there (not so much now...he doesn't have that physique anymore, LOL). He also had someone to train him to get that physique and while others could do it on their own, it requires a tremendous effort that many just don't have the resources to put in.

Goal Story & PicturesBlogPep Talk Blog
sontaikle is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 01:02 PM   #5
Candeka's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Canada
Posts: 926

S/C/G: 162/see ticker/130

Height: 5'6


As said by sontaikle, I believe it is a good aim for people to reach, even if just slightly under or a tad over. However, it's not going to be accurate for everyone. I am within a healthy BMI now but my fat percentage if through the roof. With that being said, BMI is a great goal.

139:February 27th, 2013
Candeka is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 01:14 PM   #6
Senior Member
suzukigurl's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Chicago, Il
Posts: 227

S/C/G: 285/249.6/175

Height: 5'7"


I use the BMI calculation as a positive motivational tool, and nothing else. Many BMI calculators will even state somewhere that it does not take into consideration if its calculating fat or muscle weight but again it's just a tool. When I started my weight loss journey I was Morbidly Obese according to my BMI calculation now I have come down to Class II obese. I love being able to see with this tool that I am making progress! My current goal weight is 175lbs (5' 7")this still puts me in a category of being overweight and I could really care less about that. I will be a very healthy happy 175lb woman. Most tools are just that tools use them for what they are worth use them as a positive, and if you can't find a positive in it ditch it and don't use it at all!

Starting weight 285lbs
Skinny Mini Goal #1 Hit 1/4 of total Goal weight 27.5lbs Accomplished
Skinny Mini Goal #2 Hit 1/2 of total Goal weight 55lbs
Skinny Mini Goal #3 Hit 3/4 of total Goal weight 82.5lbs
Overall weight goal is to lose 110lbs
suzukigurl is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 06:15 PM   #7
Senior Member
guacamole's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,676

S/C/G: HW 212/148/130~174/139/130

Height: 5'4


I use the BMI scale as a general guideline. My next mini-goal is to get to 149lbs, which will place me officially in the "normal" weight range. It's just another milestone for me, but I don't think BMI tells the full story of a person's health or appearance.
May Day Challenge Progress

My Reboot Journey Weight: 155 - March 6, 2017
My Lowest Journey Weight: 139 - October 2016
Original Journey Starting Weight: 212 - June 2010

guacamole is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 07:51 PM   #8
Senior Member
linJber's Avatar
Join Date: May 2011
Location: NW PA
Posts: 1,609

S/C/G: 255/holding at 162/160

Height: 5'-7"


I think, like many other measures of health, it's a good guideline. And there is definitely a different BMI scale for athletes. Your trainer was making a generalization. Look at body builders - they have very little body fat and are very "dense" and if you use only a height to weight ratio, they are overweight and even obese. For those of us who are not so buff, it's a pretty good guideline to use to get you into a healthy range.


Life style change started on Jan 13, 2011. I was going to lose 100 pounds by Christmas.
I lost 93 pounds by Oct 1, 2011 and am holding there for now. We'll see what happens.
New goal: To maintain at about 160 Final Goal: To decide if I need to lose more
Just Keep On Keepin' On
linJber is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 08:50 PM   #9
TooManyDimples's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: Ormond Beach, Florida
Posts: 1,293

Height: 5'4


I look at it as purely a guideline. Everyone cannot fit into the same box. My husband is like your trainer. He's considered overweight by the BMI standards but he is not at all.

That said, I am aiming for a goal weight that would put me at a healthy BMI. I haven't been my current size in so long and I have no idea what I'll look like at 145. I might not even make it there, I might make it there and realize I can go even further. Right now it's just a guideline. Because yeah, I would like to be able to say I have a healthy BMI, but I know if I only make it to 155 and am still considered overweight, I'm not going to force myself to lose that 10 extra pounds and possible be too skinny just so I can say I have a healthy BMI.
2018 Mini Goals
250 lbs
225 lbs
199 lbs
175 lbs
150 lbs
My "If it's even possible" Goal ~ 135 lbs

Last edited by TooManyDimples; 03-04-2012 at 08:52 PM.
TooManyDimples is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 08:53 PM   #10
astrophe's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 3,855

Height: 5'8"


I agree. Like weight charts, BMI charts are just guidelines to help get you into the healthy ballpark area. They are not the final word though.

Started Jan 2016:
astrophe is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 09:07 PM   #11
Senior Member
kaplods's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Wausau, WI
Posts: 13,383

S/C/G: SW:394/310/180

Height: 5'6"


For me, right now, BMI is probably pretty accurate or may even underestimate my obesity status, because I'm not able to be very active. I know that I have too much fat and water, and not enough bone and muscle.

I'm working to reverse that, and I would love to get to the point when the scale and BMI says I'm overweight, but my doctor and I know that the "extra" weight is muscle and bone, not fat.

I don't know whether that's even possible with my health issues, but I can work toward that dream.

My husband and I have two friends who are in the "obese" BMI who are not obese (according to their doctors). One is my hubby's best friend (a man) who is extremely lean. He's also extremely athletic. He not only works out at the gym daily, he's also an avid outdoorsman/hunter/hiker... Even when he's standing or sitting he's never standing or sitting "still." He's so lean that he has the proverbial "six pack" and you can see the muscle definition in his arms and legs. He's so "buff" he could model.

We have another friend (a woman) who is "obese" by BMI but really just overweight. She does have some weight to lose, but not nearly as much as BMI would have her lose. She's also very active and athletic. You might guess that she weighs 170 or 180 lbs (about a size 12, I would guess), but she told me that she weighs 220 lbs. In my mind, there was absolutely no way she could possibly weigh that much, until I learned more about her activity level and work out routine. Wowza, even when I was young and active, I wasn't THAT active. You can see the muscle definition in her arms, but does she carry some extra weight in her butt and thighs. However for her to reach a "healthy BMI" she would have to lose muscle as well as fat.

Because we're the same height, I actually brought her a picture of myself at 225 lbs. The difference was astonishing. It does give me hope though, because often I think, "I'll never get to my goal weight of 150 lbs," and I remind myself that I don't have to, if I'm willing and able to add a lot more muscle.

It's funny, but that thought is my motivation for exercise "the more I exercise (to build muscle), the fewer pounds I'll have to lose." It will be a very long time before I need to worry about whether my BMI is the best indicator of a healthy weight, or whether I can reach full health potential. When I get closer to that point, I'll start asking for my doctor's feedback.
My Etsy shop (currently closed for the summer)

etsy link by permission from 3fc! Want to add yours? Ask them!

Last edited by kaplods; 03-04-2012 at 09:28 PM.
kaplods is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 09:21 PM   #12
Tired Of Just Surviving
SmallSteps's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Las Vegas, Nevada
Posts: 1,221

S/C/G: 300/298/200

Height: 5'7


I agree with the other posters it is a great tool used with other tools to give you a guideline. But everyone is not going to fit into the same box.

Original Journey Starting Weight 298.6 - November 11, 2011
My Lowest Journey Weight: 242.8 (-55.8) - July 30, 2012
My Reboot Journey Weight: 300.0 - January 01, 2017

5% (285.0) | 10% (270.0) | 15% (255.0) | Under 250 (249.9) | 20% (240.0) | 25% (225.0) | 30% (210.0) | 100 lost (200.0) | ONEderland (199)

SmallSteps is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 10:00 PM   #13
Senior Member
Madame Souza's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: CA
Posts: 352

S/C/G: 286/153/155

Height: 5'9


I am using BMI as a guideline because when I started at 286, I had no idea how much weight I wanted to loose or what I will look like when I do. I am closer to my goal but still don't know what I will look like when or if I reach it. Now that I am closer, I want to get rid of the flab around my middle and when I do, I will know that's what I want to be whatever that weight is.
Madame Souza is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-04-2012, 10:52 PM   #14
Started IP 8/20/14
PghGal's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 240

S/C/G: HW292/SW284/CW284/GW200

Height: 5'8"


My doctor said that use of BMI is a general tool to determine your ballpark range.

As others have mentioned, it's important to take other things into consideration --- muscle mass, frame size, etc.

Unfortunately I have a large frame/bone structure (thanks, Dad!), so I doubt I'll ever reach my "ideal" BMI.
~ Jess ~

The road to success is always under construction ...

Small steps!!!

PghGal is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 03-05-2012, 11:20 AM   #15
Posts: n/a


i think it's utter crap. norway doesn't even use it any more - they use waist-to-hip ratio as a much better indicator of health issues.

if you get two guys, both six feet and 275 they both have a BMI of 37.3 even if one has a 52" waist and the other has a 32" waist!

if you want guidelines or ballparks, better to stick to the old insurance charts - they're about as accurate and they're easier to comprehend.
  Reply With Quote

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Eating at maintenance for a week (or more) - Thoughts and advice welcome! JenMusic Weight Loss Support 49 03-21-2011 10:05 AM
My thoughts on lose skin Charbar 100 lb. Club 20 06-08-2010 11:30 PM
Thoughts on self-worth paris81 100 lb. Club 19 12-30-2009 04:37 PM
Killer Thoughts on maintenance... MrsJim Living Maintenance 14 02-02-2005 02:56 PM

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:06 AM.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2