Dr Hope - 5th appointment
Food Tests, Low Stress Weight Loss December 27th, 2007I saw Dr Hope just before leaving for the holidays. I’ll sum up the holidays by saying only that I was not doing anything I should have. No food diary, and when there is no food diary it means things are BAD. I went for one very short walk, I had a few servings of fruit, but it was not a weight-loss or weight-management few days by any stretch of the imagination. I wasn’t off to a great start yesterday morning either, but luckily didn’t let a slightly exaggerated breakfast become an excuse for torching the whole day, and by the afternoon had actually pushed myself out the door for a short walk. So - all is forgiven, now back on track.
I began my discussion w Dr Hope on the Pizza Test where my lessons apparently were learned correctly - a food like any other. I then talked to her about my self-designed Dessert Test and she was very pleased, and again seemed to think I’d done quite well.
She did, however, ask me if I’d cut back at other parts of the meal, knowing I was having dessert. And there the answer is no. I’ve been enjoying this “I can eat anything” diet too much. I like paying attention to the pleasure aspect of my food - that I’m pretty good at. But the truth is I am eating “anything” and not paying much attention to the fact that I want to lose weight.
Enter Dr Hope…. The aspects of the Dr Hope approach are basically as follows :
- You can eat anything. No food is off limits. You can have cake for breakfast and bacon for dessert if thats what you really want.
- Enjoy what you eat
- Eat when hungry
- Eat to the point of satisfaction (not FULLNESS)
Probably there will be more, but for now it’s pretty much that. Dessert tests & Pizza tests teach you in fact you can really eat anything. There are no “bad” foods, no “good” foods.
Enjoying your food is a question of paying attention. Slowing down. Concentrating. Being able to separate “so-so” from “spectacular”. Eventually, being demanding about what you eat - only eating the very good things, and leaving the rest behind. I’m making some progress on this, but there is still a good ways to go - more often than not I eat out of habit, not taking the mental energy to focus on the pleasure.
The last 2 items, paying attention to my hunger, and eating to satisfaction, I am VERY BAD at. Again, I’ve made some progress, but we’re coming from 0% on this one, so occasional semi-attention isn’t much progress.
Dr Hope gave me some more structure for these, which will help (especially if I start to put them to use, which I haven’t done since I’d seen her, as we left for the holidays just after my appointment).
What I’m supposed to do now :
- Stop for a pause in the middle of each meal. Set down the silverware. Don’t eat for a minute or two. Evaluate your hunger that remains. Then continue.
- Try to not finish everything on your plate.
- Pay attention to being relaxed while eating.
- Pay attention to portions.
Ok, I’m admitting here that I’m not even going to try to deal w the portion issue right away. The relaxation thing I can handle, it seems to come pretty naturally when I focus on evaluating the pleasure I’m getting from the foods, so that’s do-able.
The others will be HARD, however.
Stop in the middle of a meal. Yikes.
Evaluate how much hunger remains. Double yikes.
Try to leave something on the plate. I’ve worked on this from time to time since September (when I read “Mindless Eating”). Even with effort I find this hard, but it is do-able, and it is a great feeling for me to see something left over.
There you have it, my next set of challenges. I’m going to change my journal document to incorporate this already, that should help keep me focused.
December 27th, 2007 at 2:56 pm
I never finish everything on my plate no matter how hungry I am. My grandmother who was always as thin as a rail always use to tell me that, “a true lady never cleans her plate, she always leaves something on it.”
I have never forgotten her stern looks or her evil eye if I took that last bite, so even now I never finish what is on my plate.
December 27th, 2007 at 3:53 pm
Well, you knew there had to be a catch with Dr Hope’s easy approach.
You will tackle these next “rules” with ease and grace. It won’t be as hard as you are imagining.
December 27th, 2007 at 5:08 pm
“The last 2 items, paying attention to my hunger, and eating to satisfaction, I am VERY BAD at.”
Those are both really hard. I find that I have hunger mixed up with all sorts of other things–thirsty? I think I’m hungry. Bored? I think I’m hungry. I’ve even had moments where I realized that what I thought was hunger was really that I needed to use the bathroom! What the heck is THAT?
And as for feeling full, I think my body just has a very delayed response. On multiple occasions over the past couple of weeks, I’ve come to the end of a meal and thought, I’m still really, really hungry. A good fifteen or twenty minutes later, I realize I’m actually quite full.
Keep us posted on how it’s going!
December 27th, 2007 at 6:55 pm
>> No food is off limits. You can have cake for breakfast and bacon for dessert if thats what you really want
December 27th, 2007 at 6:59 pm
I got cut off! I’ll write it out again:
In the book I’m reading “FrenchWomenDon’tGetFat” the author suggests to practice saying “No” with the idea of saying “Yes” to something else. In this way, we never feel anything is all or nothing, but perhaps something else. I guess it just helps to know that nothing is off limits, really, but that the focus be on quantity. A “little bit of everything, but in small portions”. Hard work!
December 27th, 2007 at 8:21 pm
Thanks for your comments on my blog. I think you’ve got some great ideas - keep at it. It’s amazing how some people (us) don’t develop the ability to feel satisfied and full like others. About leaving food, my hubby is a clean-plater from years of training growing up and never had a problem until middle-age. Now he needs to allow himself to leave food on the plate. The portions in restaurants are outrageous and he still tries to eat them all.
December 27th, 2007 at 9:15 pm
thank you for you comments. i am finding that i like dr. hope’s approach. and i dont limit myself as far as what i eat, just how much i eat. i enjoy my food more when im not stressed and when i can slow down and pay attention to what im eating. i think portion controls are the key. just my 2 cents.
December 27th, 2007 at 9:47 pm
I think those are great ideas and I’m looking forward to seeing how they work for you.
December 28th, 2007 at 5:47 am
That last one is particularly hard. Sometimes you’re just shovelling food into your mouth, and you think ‘why the hell am I still eating this?!! it doesn’t even taste good anymore.’ since the first few bites are the most satisfying really. I find setting down the silver for EVERY bite results in the most satisfying meal. Incredibly long…but satisfying.
December 28th, 2007 at 6:21 am
Wow - it sounds very exciting - this totally different approach to eating.
I can’t wait to hear how you experience this next set of challenges….
thanks for sharing with us!
December 28th, 2007 at 8:15 am
Great stuff again from Dr Hope
I read that it takes 10-20 minutes for your stomach to tell your brain that you’ve had enough.
Plus: our stomachs are really not that big. About as big as your fist. Something to bear in mind!
One of the things that i find helps people too is MORE CHEWING (as well as Think Before You Eat, Mindful/Relaxed Eating, Reduced Portion Sizes and Pausing During Eating etc)
Generally speaking we chew our food only until we feel we can swallow it without choking. This puts unnecessary strain on our digestive systems and, we may miss out on nutrients because our bodies find it hard to process big lumps of food.
Digestion actually starts in the mouth… unchewed food can cause your digestive system to over-produce acid which in turn may lead to indigestion and general discomfort.
Mmmm, sounds like Xmas!
Keep up the good works… Best, Pete.
December 28th, 2007 at 6:27 pm
I like her approach, she seems to be making this whole ordeal very do-able for you. Which basically makes it much easier to lose weight. But, I like her ideas very much. I think she’s basically saying to eat in moderation. “Moderation” is different for everyone, so it seems like she’s trying to help you find your point of moderation. Which is great. I wish I had a Dr Hope here in the states!!!