6thJanuary

Help, Please!

A group of teachers here at the school are starting a “Biggest Loser” thing where we pay $10.00 a week and it goes on for ten weeks. Winner take all! I’m not interested because I’m not about to dish out my money so it can be grabbed by a 27 year old Male teacher who has 150 pounds to lose. We’re talking big bucks here because the winner will wind up with a BIG chunk of money (16 people have already signed up). I’m being told that it’s fair because it will be based on percentages and I’m telling them it’s not fair because a 57 year old woman who needs to lose 40 pounds doesn’t stand a chance against a 27 year old man who needs to lose 150 pounds. So…everyone’s asking how we figure out what’s fair. I don’t know….I looked on the internet to see if I could find any way of calculating weight loss that takes gender, body fat, and age into consideration and I’m not finding anything. Anyone got any ideas?

4:30 - Home again. Thanks for all the advice. I don’t think I’m going to participate at the school. I’m not sure exactly what would be fair and I really don’t think I’d stand much of a chance of winning so I feel like I’d be throwing my money away. It would be worth it, even if I didn’t win, if it kept me motivated but I don’t think it’s going to motivate me because I have a pretty strong feeling that I couldn’t possibly win so I don’t think it would work to my advantage. If they were going to work out together or form a support group or something, it would be worth it but they’re not doing anything but paying and weighing. Don’t think that’s going to get me motivated.

I want to spend some time rethinking and making new goals but I’m being run ragged again. I have an hour or so and then I have to go back to school. Tomorrow, I’m going to exercise! At least I’ve kept to my diet today!

Have to leave in a few minutes but I took a look at Anngirl’s blog and it made me start thinking:

Ann:  “It’s so hard to wish you weren’t as big as you are now. It’s hard to look in the mirror and NOT be repulsed by your own reflection. The worst thing about it is that it’s no one’s fault but your own. So every time you pass by something you would normally eat - it eats at you a little because you CAN’T have it.

Because all of those shouldn’ts end up distorting your body and ultimately wreaking havoc on your self esteem.”

I got to thinking about that and it came to me that we’re all a bunch of winners!  We’re winners because we deal with this all the time.  We don’t give up.  We keep fighting the good fight even though we’re sick to death of it.  If we didn’t try, then we could wreak havoc on the self esteem.  We do, though.  We try.  We keep fighting.

All the women in my family are obese.  That’s the way it is.  That’s the way I’m genetically engineered.  Still…I’ve dieted and exercised my entire adult life and that’s the only reason that I was able to keep my weight fairly controlled.  Even now, I suppose I should be much heavier than I am but I keep trying to get rid of another forty pounds.  I’m 57 years old and I have bad ankles but I keep trying.  That’s something to feel good about.  We fight a good fight, chickies.

9 Comments

sterling says 6th January @ 13:08

You’d be surprised at the odds using percentages, really. I’ve participated in two. The last challenge I was the second lightest person, yet took 1st place (WOO!) using the percentage method. We had all types in the contest - males and females, some with 200+ to lose some who wanted to lose 10.

grabthebull says 6th January @ 13:58

How about: You win regardless. That sounds fair. Whaddya think?

kt

P.S. If they do elect that plan, you owe me at least a dinner out.

eryn76 says 6th January @ 14:57

the one’s we’ve done here have been on percentages of body fat lost.

could they break it up into age groups? that would make the pot a little smaller, but keep it fair.

firefly says 6th January @ 15:16

I don’t think there’s a “fair” way to do it. I was chosen to participate in a radio station weight loss contest last year. Based on percentage. I was the smallest, thinnest contestant but I worked my ass off… and lost to the only male participant. And by only a little bit. But at 5′2″ I just didn’t stand a chance against a 6′3″ guy with over 100 pounds to lose.

brseay says 6th January @ 16:30

You might be surprised that over 10 weeks anyone could win. We did a similar challenge last year and a friend of mine took the cake and she was one of the smallest people in the contest. There were men as well as women and people w/100+ pounds to lose. I would think that since it’s a longer challenge that even his advantage of being male and big will fall away if he’s not dedicated.

Be careful, though, b/c these can backfire. I do well w/these challenges as long as I have a chance of winning but as soon as I’m out of the running I tend to give up. I know, sore loser. Instead, I’m thinking of organizing something where each person sets their own individual goal and as long as they meet their goal they get their money back. If not, the kitty is split between those who did. That way everyone can be supportive of each other and people may not get as discouraged.

sterling says 6th January @ 17:16

Oh brseay - LOVE that idea, you’re a genius.

inkheartmeg says 6th January @ 18:55

Great ideas. I’m curious about all of this and will search to see if there’s any contests like that starting around here for me. Hey, speaking of Biggest Loser, I think the next season starts tonight. Also I recorded Dietribe last night but haven’t watched it yet.

Success to all.

2dogs1lady says 6th January @ 20:33

Hey girlfriend!
Good blog! About this loser contest thingy..everyone who loses weight will be a WINNER…$ or not, as long as they do it healthily. (iz dat a werd *snicker)
Mom’s have a habit of putting themselves last..seldom having time to look in the mirror at themselves and take the time to stop and LOVE what they see. Society has a warped sense of what is beautiful vs what is real.
Patty, the girls in my family are ALL overweight. Obese actually, and i struggle with what I have become, but I am also refusing, and even sometimes winning with not letting that define me. Sometimes I feel people do not see me, just a fat person, but you know what, if they can not see ME, then they do not deserve to see ME.
So, love yourself regardless, good or bad day, because the inner beauty is always the real beauty..ok, so i am rambling..but there is a message there…

Susan aka Happy Hag says 6th January @ 20:42

Patty, design some “Cold(Water)Cash Creek” coupons ~ say $10.00 a pound ~ and reward yourself with some new Spring threads as you drop those pounds. (or I’ll design ‘em and send them to you, if you need more accountability to the reward.)

Or you can send anonymous packages of goodies from Godiva to your closest competitors. Muwha-ha-ha!

But don’t do this - load your pockets with lead bird shot at the initial weigh in. ;)

On the serious side though, even if you don’t think you have a chance of winning, it would still get you pointed in the right direction. It would cost less than Weight Watchers per week and the inspiration/determination would be well worth the cost of “losing” the competition, IMHO.

Even though you were a “loser”, you would still be a winner. Ah the paradoxes of life!


Your Comments

You must be logged in,to post a comment.