:: Free 2 Be :: the Odyssey ::

18 Feb, 2010

BMI - In Pictures!

Posted by: delitaagain In: Motivation

This is a re-post from December 2008, based on a great post on body image by Gracie789 on Fat to Fabulous. The post is: Miss Perceptions.

Be sure to click also to see pictures of *real people*  with height, weight and BMI measure.

BMI is a wake-up call for many but has fallen from grace as a marker. Mainly, because it doesn’t take into account the weight of muscle or make allowance for “large bones.” For example, weight lifters are sometimes categorized by BMI as overweight even though their body fat percentage is low.

You probably don’t hear much about heavy bones, but mine are 99th percentile hardness so they weigh more than average bones, especially more than the bones of someone with osteoporosis, which are sometimes called “swiss cheese bones.” 

But, I digress. Point is, BMI is not necessarily an accurate measure.

Kate Harding put together a collection of images on flickr of people with their BMI. Some may amaze you. I found it very interesting.

Illustrated BMI Categories

Body fat percentage is the by far preferred method of body analysis today, but I haven’t seen a collection like Ms. Harding’s for it.

Play along: Does this collection help you *see* yourself? How did it make you feel?

10 Responses to "BMI - In Pictures!"

1 | bosoxfan

December 23rd, 2008 at 10:36 pm

Avatar

This was really interesting. Although I do have to say, at 178ish pounds, I know I would be classified as obese for my height. I don’t consider myself obese, definitely overweight though. But really, when you look at some of those pictures and weights, some of them DO honestly seem accurate. I’m not sure about the “normal” and “overweight” categories because they seemed kinda crazy, but the obese and morbidly obese didn’t seem that far off the mark.

2 | delitaagain

December 24th, 2008 at 11:59 am

Avatar

bosoxfan - that is exactly the reaction I had. Some of the *normal* looked thin to me and some of the overweight sure did not look overweight to me, they looked GOOD! Maybe those had hidden muscle that pushed their weight up but their size stayed down. I’d rather be there than look like I’m on the verge of wasting away. Obese and morbidly obese usually made sense to me, and I’m so grateful to be in the obese, no longer in the morbidly obese category. Yep, interesting. Thanks so much for stopping by! Happy Christmas to you and yours! Delita

3 | round

February 19th, 2010 at 3:19 am

Avatar

I’ve seen this before, I’ve followed Kate Harding for a long time, but it’s always interesting.

I definitely have some distorted self-image things going on - now that I’m a bit smaller I keep thinking I’m bigger than I am. Last weekend we were at the theater and I was seated next to a very big girl and her very big mom. At intermission I said to my husband how glad I was not to be that big anymore & he told me I was never that big (well, at least since he’s known me).

I have days when I feel enormous and days when I feel almost “normal” sized. It’s quite weird.

4 | brseay

February 19th, 2010 at 10:36 pm

Avatar

I’m so glad to have run into this b/c I’m always trying to “see” myself in others. I have asked my hubby to point out people who are about my size but understandably he has declined to play this game w/me. Although I’m feeling fat and lumpy right now I realize that based on some of the other pictures I don’t look too bad.

5 | delitaagain

February 20th, 2010 at 12:29 am

Avatar

round, I know what you mean. Somedays I feel downright *reasonable* and then other days a hopeless bletch. Is *bletch* a word? Yah, buddy.

6 | delitaagain

February 20th, 2010 at 12:30 am

Avatar

brseay, smart man! I got that out of it, too - I could be a lot worse, I look better than I feel most of the time. How much good a little more weight loss/exercise would do me. I’m very grateful for this. Delita

7 | Sandi DeFalco

February 20th, 2010 at 10:50 am

Avatar

Wow, looking at those pictures and their info, I would fall into the ‘obese’ category. I have always ‘labeled’ myself as overweight, not obese! This is a wakeup call to see how others view me. I’m still in denial of the word obese, that’s for bigger than me people.
Yesterday I had an appointment with a fitness trainer at the gym. She showed me how to use the elliptical and recumbent bike cardio machines. She wanted me to use the treadmill too, but I declined since I hate with a passion the treadmill! She had me try an AB crunch machine, but with my 3 herniated discs in my neck, it caused uncomfortable cracking in my neck. So, my alternative is to do at home while lying in bed, leg lifts.
I have 3 different exercises to do at home, which I’ve already done this morning. The cardio machines are for 4 times a week, and free weights twice a week. Somewhere in between I have 2 aquatic classes. I’m thinking of trying the water ‘Zumba’ class. We’ll see, it’s a level above what I’m already doing.
So, I guess after seeing those photos, I’m going to have to work really hard to get out of the ‘obese’ category! YIKES! ;)

8 | A.

February 21st, 2010 at 11:57 am

Avatar

Wow-. All these people looked “normal” to me. It was interesting to see, and how effed up the BMI concept is. I am morbidly obese BTW. wow.

Thanks for this!

Aj

9 | delitaagain

February 21st, 2010 at 9:49 pm

Avatar

Sandi - you go, woman! I am so proud of you for all you are doing! And soooooo glad you didn’t let her get you on the crunch thing. They have proved crunches (even thousands of them) won’t get rid of belly fat, anyway. I did what a *trainer* said once when it caused a *catch* in my shoulder and ended up with a two-year shoulder re-hab. Never again! Some of those machines ruin you! Good for you on paying attention to your body and following through on all this. I agree about *obese.* My heart has always gone out to really fat women - but I never saw myself as one, and, I was. Hmm.

10 | delitaagain

February 21st, 2010 at 9:50 pm

Avatar

Aj, I understand. I tend to think I’m more normal now after losing 50 pounds and then I catch the mirror. Still, I am way better than I was. Thanks for dropping by! Good to meet you!

Comment Form


  • tjnorth: I spent some time with my sister this summer and she lost about 100 pounds (she won't really say) three years ago by eating the good stuff (veggies,
  • brseay: Wow, what incredible pictures! So good to see you pop up here. Many of the regulars have disappeared so it's nice to see a friendly face. My ch
  • shoecrazy: Hi Delita! Well, I have soo many challenges... But, I had a trainer who said "you can't out run a bad diet" so my challenge is my keeping my food unde